Quantum computers are still far from cracking Bitcoin — even if headlines promise otherwise. This is precisely the conclusion reached by AI developer Ben Sigman, who analyzed two high-profile announcements from recent times and showed why figures like "40 times fewer errors" sound impressive but do not change the real threat picture for the blockchain.
What the experiments actually showed
To crack Bitcoin, a quantum machine needs to derive the private key to a wallet. Protection is provided by the ECDSA algorithm, and an attack requires an exceptionally powerful and exceptionally precise device that does not exist today.
The first announcement from Google, which Sigman analyzed, concerned the reduction of errors in quantum computing. Scientists demonstrated on real hardware that the number of errors can be reduced — this is indeed a genuine step forward. However, only about 8% of attempts were successful, and the error rate is still approximately a million times higher than what is permissible for cracking Bitcoin. Moreover, this method had already been accounted for in calculations published earlier this year: the experiment merely confirmed previous estimates and did not accelerate the timeline.
The second announcement — from Anthropic — promised schemes "17 times more efficient." The AI optimized one of the blocks of a future attack and noticeably reduced the number of operations in it. But when the attack was modeled in its entirety, the resource savings amounted to only 0 to 30%.
Loud numbers are misleading
Quantum technology developers need to demonstrate progress, investors expect breakthroughs, and the media love impressive numbers. But if you improve one detail by 40 times, the entire machine does not become 40 times closer to cracking Bitcoin.
Progress is indeed being made: according to estimates, fewer and fewer computational units — qubits — are required for an attack. Previously the figure was around 2,300 logical qubits, then 1,175, and now perhaps around 900 may suffice. This is a serious reduction, but such equipment does not yet exist, and the gap with the current level is enormous.
That is why Sigman advises relying on expert assessments rather than headlines. In a Global Risk Institute survey, 26 specialists estimated the probability of such a machine appearing in the next 10 years at 28–49%, and in the next 15 years at 51–70%. The developer emphasizes that he is not disputing the importance of quantum development; what concerns him is only the excessive enthusiasm around individual components of a machine that does not yet exist.
Cryptalist analysis: The quantum threat to Bitcoin remains real but deferred to a horizon of decades, not months. The market should perceive individual technical announcements as incremental progress, not as a signal to revise long-term risks. For investors, the key indicator remains independent expert assessments of timelines, not marketing figures from press releases.