The prospect of a merger between Tesla and SpaceX — two companies each valued at over $1 trillion — looks far more complicated than it appears at first glance. Steve Westly, a former Tesla board member and managing partner of The Westly Group, identifies three key obstacles: valuation of the companies, alignment with regulators, and Tesla's operations in China.

Westly expects the relevant board committees to soon begin discussing a potential deal. At the same time, Elon Musk himself, who heads both companies, has stated that the committees have not yet developed agreed-upon terms.

Who determines the merger price

The first barrier is valuation. The exchange ratio depends directly on it: how many SpaceX shares the holder of one Tesla share will receive. Musk cannot participate in meetings of the independent directors because he is an interested party.

"Many believe that a SpaceX-Tesla merger is guaranteed, but that is an exaggeration," Elon Musk said.

On September 29, Tesla received approval from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for a voting program for retail investors, allowing small shareholders to transfer their votes to the board of directors in advance. According to Westly, such a measure makes it easier to move closer to a deal, although he still considers the SEC approval itself one of the barriers.

What will happen to Tesla's Shanghai plant in a merger

China is another obstacle. About 20% of SpaceX's revenue for 2025 comes from U.S. federal agencies. Because of this, national security questions may arise regarding the operation of Tesla's Shanghai plant — the source of more than half of the company's supplies. JPMorgan analysts highlight the need for additional approvals, especially in China, as a potential point of slowdown for the merger.

In July, reports emerged that Tesla's management was instructed to prepare for a spin-off of the Chinese business. Musk denied this information.

Westly believes Tesla needs to show growth not only in the automobile segment to confirm its status as a technology company. Meanwhile, revenue from the automotive business in the third quarter declined by 3% compared to last year.

Concluding such a deal will require approval from shareholders of both companies and, according to analysts' estimates, regulators in the U.S. and China.

Cryptalist analysis: The announced deal carries significant regulatory and geopolitical risk that the market is currently underestimating. The China factor could become the most unpredictable element: any uncertainty surrounding the Shanghai plant will hit Tesla's valuation and complicate the negotiation process. Investors should factor into their expectations a lengthy, multi-stage approval scenario rather than a quick synergistic effect.