Grayscale analysts conducted a fundamental valuation of ten popular crypto assets, creating two rankings: yield for token holders and adjusted benefit with dilution taken into account. The results clearly demonstrate that high economic activity of a protocol does not always translate into profit for the investor.

Who actually generates income for holders

In the first ranking, reflecting net yield for holders, Hyperliquid (HYPE) leads with 8.0%. It is followed by Lighter (LIT) with 7.9%, and PancakeSwap (CAKE) with 2.6% rounds out the top three. Next in the list are Aerodrome (AERO) and Uniswap (UNI).

Notably, five of the top-10 tokens had negative yield for holders. At the very bottom of the ranking are Curve Finance (CRV) with -5.5% and Jupiter (JUP) with -2.6%. The key reason is dilution: the emission of new tokens exceeds the rewards that holders receive.

Adjusted yield changes the balance of power

The second ranking, which accounts for adjusted benefit, puts PancakeSwap in first place — 14.4%, followed by Lighter with 14.1% and HYPE with 9.8%. Jupiter deserves special attention: its adjusted yield is 3.5%, while the yield for holders remains negative. This is a clear example of how a profitable protocol may not create value for the owner of its token.

Grayscale's methodology calculates holder yield as the sum of staking rewards and market buybacks, minus the volume of newly issued tokens. If emission exceeds the benefits for holders, their shares are diluted — even with high economic activity of the protocol.

Zach Pandl, head of research at Grayscale, draws a direct parallel: bitcoin is comparable to digital gold, whereas many other crypto assets can legitimately be valued by cash flows — similar to stocks. Protocols earn on trading and lending fees, and token buybacks and burning part of the supply pass this value to holders. However, emission often reduces the effect to zero.

Cryptalist analysis: The publication of two rankings signals the maturity of the institutional approach to valuing altcoins — the market is shifting from purely speculative narratives to the analysis of cash flows and tokenomics. The divergence between gross and adjusted yield for a number of assets points to a systemic dilution risk that institutional investors will take into account when forming portfolios. The priority when choosing tokens is shifting in favor of projects with sustainable buyback mechanics and restrained emission.