The decline in gold and silver prices since January is not a bursting bubble, but merely a pause in a long-term uptrend. Relative to US equities, precious metals still look undervalued, which means their main growth is yet to come.

Metals have been getting cheaper since the start of the year after two years of powerful gains. Some analysts and many bitcoin supporters rushed to declare a burst bubble and predict a decade of decline by analogy with the peaks of 1980 and 2011. However, such a conclusion does not withstand scrutiny by key macroeconomic indicators.

The ratio to the S&P 500 as a market thermometer

The most telling tool is the ratio of the metal's price to the S&P 500 index. When it rises, the metal outperforms stocks; when it falls, the opposite is true. Historically high values signal overheating and an imminent end to the rally, while low values signal undervaluation and the metal's advantage over stocks.

Currently, the indicator for gold is near the lower boundary. In past cycles it rose far higher:

  • in the 1970s, gold outperformed the S&P 500 by 2,011%, with the ratio peaking at 7.8;
  • in the 2000s, the gain was 840%, with a peak of 1.7;
  • now gold has added only 101% relative to the index, and the January maximum was 0.8.

The picture for silver is similar. In the 1970s it rose relative to the index by 3,238%, in the 2000s by 1,119%, and in the current cycle by only 293%. The silver-to-S&P 500 ratio is holding near the lower boundary across the entire history of observations.

"If this was a bubble, it was one of the most sluggish and disappointing in history," the author of the corresponding analytical work summarizes the situation.

In late 2025 and early 2026, metals were indeed slightly overheated. But there was no mass mania, when everyone rushes into the market. It was precisely such manias that previously ended the great bull cycles in precious metals. Consequently, that stage is still ahead.

What this means for investors

The main conclusion: selling gold and silver during a correction is premature. Prices will ultimately go far above the January highs, and the bull market that started in spring 2024 will last for many more years.

The second signal is that the stock market is more dangerous than it seems. Since March 2009, the S&P 500 has risen by 1,052%, that is, more than 11-fold. This growth is largely artificial: it was fueled by the Fed's zero rates and the printing of trillions of dollars after the 2008 crisis and the pandemic. Stocks represent a bubble that will burst sooner or later — and then money will flee from them into gold and silver, driving up their prices.

The third indicator is the real effective exchange rate of the dollar. It is currently around 104 points against a historical average of 93, meaning the dollar is overvalued. This is exactly how past cycles of metal growth began — in the early 1970s and 2000s — and they ended in 1980 and 2011, when the dollar became undervalued.

For crypto investors the signal is also unambiguous: the thesis that bitcoin will replace gold as the main store of value is not confirmed, and the decline in metals is not a sign of their obsolescence.

Cryptalist analysis: The current correction in precious metals fits within the framework of a healthy pullback after a two-year rally and is not accompanied by the capitulation signs characteristic of the final stages of bubbles. The metals-to-S&P 500 ratio and the overvalued dollar form a macro backdrop favorable for a resumption of growth. Institutional investors would be well advised to view current levels as an accumulation zone rather than an exit.