Stablecoin transfers did not help a borrower from Kaliningrad prove that the debt had been repaid. The appellate court upheld the ruling to recover from him and the guarantor company the entire loan amount of 20.6 million rubles, interest for the delay, and court costs — totaling approximately 27.5 million rubles.

The court did not recognize the USDT transfer data as confirmation of either an agreement to settle in cryptocurrency or the very fact that the creditor received the funds. This case is becoming an important precedent for the entire market of private lending in digital assets.

What happened

The loan of 20.6 million rubles was issued interest-free in September 2023 for a term of 45 days. The funds were intended to replenish the working capital of the company that acted as guarantor under the agreement. The debt was not repaid on time, and the creditor went to court.

The Moskovsky District Court of Kaliningrad sided with the creditor, recovering from the borrower and the company the entire loan amount, about 6.92 million rubles in interest for the delay, and a state duty of 73,276 rubles from each.

The defendants disagreed and filed an appeal. They stated that the parties had agreed to repay the loan in cryptocurrency. According to their calculations, from November 2023 to January 2025, the borrower sent 207,719 USDT to a crypto wallet, which was valued at approximately 19.18 million rubles. Thus, only about 1.42 million rubles remained unpaid. As evidence, the defendants presented transfer calculations and correspondence certified by a notary.

The judicial panel rejected these arguments. The ruling states that the calculations with dates and USDT amounts do not prove the main point: they do not show that the parties had ever agreed to repay the loan in cryptocurrency. It was not confirmed who owns the wallet to which the funds were sent, and there is no evidence that the transfers were intended specifically for the creditor as repayment of the loan, rather than for other persons who provided money for cryptocurrency investments. The first-instance decision was left unchanged, and the appeals were rejected.

The main lesson

For the court, a crypto transfer by itself means nothing. It sees only the fact that tokens were sent to some address — who is behind that address and why the money was sent does not follow from the blockchain. Therefore, the purpose of the payment must be proven separately, and in the Kaliningrad case this was not achieved.

For cryptocurrency transfers to be counted as repayment of a debt, at a minimum the following is necessary:

  • a written agreement that the loan may be repaid in cryptocurrency, specifying the asset and the conversion rate;
  • confirmation that the recipient's wallet belongs specifically to the creditor;
  • evidence that each transfer was made toward this loan, and not under other arrangements.

Correspondence and one's own calculations, even notarized, did not play such a role in this case. The court found in them confirmation of neither the agreement nor the ownership of the wallet.

Formally, this is a decision in a single dispute and is not binding on other courts. But it shows how courts currently view cryptocurrency settlements. Anyone who repays a debt with stablecoins "by word of mouth" risks paying twice — first in USDT, and then in rubles by court decision.

Cryptalist analysis: The case demonstrates a systemic gap between the technical irreversibility of blockchain transfers and the requirements of legal provability that courts impose on financial transactions. As the volume of P2P lending in stablecoins grows, such disputes will multiply, which means the market will need a standardized practice for formalizing crypto debt obligations. Until it emerges, it is reasonable for institutional and private participants to regard any USDT settlements outside legally formalized contracts as carrying a double risk — loss of the asset and repeated recovery in fiat equivalent.