The Attorney General's Office of the US state of Utah has filed 14 charges against the prediction market platform Kalshi and its co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara for promoting illegal gambling. Notably, 13 of them fall into the felony category — this moves the dispute over the status of prediction markets from the realm of regulatory disagreements into full-fledged criminal prosecution.
The Utah case is becoming one of the harshest episodes in the growing confrontation between prediction market operators and local US regulators. Kalshi consistently insists that its contracts are financial instruments rather than bets and operate within the framework of federal regulation. However, at the level of individual states, such argumentation meets resistance: local authorities view event contracts as a form of gambling subject to the relevant prohibitions.
Why this matters for the market
Criminal charges against the platform's founders represent a qualitatively new level of pressure. If other states begin to apply similar measures, prediction markets will face fragmentation of access to the American audience and rising legal costs. For the industry, this is a signal: federal legitimacy does not guarantee protection from local prosecutions.
The situation around Kalshi also amplifies uncertainty for the entire event contracts segment, which has been actively gaining momentum in recent years and attracting institutional attention. The outcome of the case in Utah could become a precedent determining where the line will be drawn between an innovative financial product and gambling.
Cryptalist analysis: The escalation to the criminal level indicates that the regulatory conflict around prediction markets will be resolved not through compromise but through judicial precedents. For investors, this means the persistence of legal risk in the prediction markets sector and a likely widening of the discount to valuations of such platforms until the courts' position becomes clear. The outcome of the Kalshi case could set the framework for the entire industry for years to come.