The Moscow Exchange recorded a record turnover in October — 212.9 trillion rubles. At the same time, the explosive growth of IT stocks on November 2, where VK shares gained more than 23% at the start of trading, raises well-founded doubts among analysts about sustainability: the lion's share of activity comes from the money market, not the equity segment.
The surge of interest in individual IT stocks does not yet mean a mass inflow of capital into equities in November. The bulk of the exchange's turnover is formed on the money market, where banks and professional participants raise and place funds on a short-term basis. That is precisely why a private investor should evaluate first and foremost the fundamental sustainability of specific issuers, rather than record trading volumes.
What made up the 212.9 trillion ruble turnover
Stocks, depositary receipts and units accounted for only 2.8 trillion rubles, while the average daily turnover in this segment reached 125.1 billion rubles. In October, issuers placed bonds worth 1.6 trillion rubles, of which overnight issues accounted for 221 billion rubles. Secondary trading in corporate, regional and government bonds brought 2.4 trillion rubles of turnover, or 108.7 billion rubles on average per day.
The derivatives market turnover amounted to 16.7 trillion rubles — an average of 759.1 billion rubles per day. The money market accounted for almost 80% of total turnover: operations there reached 169 trillion rubles, or 7.7 trillion rubles daily. REPO — short-term loans secured by securities — makes up the bulk of these operations: participants concluded transactions with the central counterparty worth 66.2 trillion rubles, and with clearing participation certificates — 67.8 trillion rubles. Trading in precious metals (spot and swap) in the main mode added another 590 billion rubles.
Against this backdrop, the equity market with a turnover of 2.8 trillion rubles remains a small part of exchange activity — even moderate purchases can sharply move the quotes of individual securities.
What drove IT stocks up
VK securities rose the most on November 2: at the start of trading, quotes climbed more than 23%. Shares of other issuers in the sector gained 5–11% and updated multi-month highs. Astra Group quotes rose 11% at the start of the day, to 245.5 rubles — a maximum since June 1. Softline securities rose 8% (to 55.8 rubles, a maximum since August 20), B2B-RTS — by 7.6% (to 144.6 rubles, a maximum since June 8). Shares of Bazis, IVA and Diasoft each gained 5%.
Turnovers in these securities turned out to be more modest: trading volume exceeded 1 billion rubles only in Astra Group, while for the other companies it amounted to 100–300 million rubles. Yandex shares gained 0.5% at the start of trading but almost immediately went into the red.
The sharp growth of the sector is attributed to speculative play, although VK's quotes were additionally supported by decent IFRS financial statements. There is no point in counting on sustainable growth of all IT stocks right now — those who bought at the peak risk a pullback if speculative demand dries up.
Why the dispute between the Central Bank and the exchange matters for investors
Speculative jumps in quotes are especially dangerous where investors lack information about companies — and this is exactly what the discussion between the regulator and the exchange at the corporate governance forum was about. First Deputy Chairman of the Central Bank Vladimir Chistyukhin reproached the Moscow Exchange for the fact that, when discussing new requirements for listing, data disclosure and shareholder meetings, it more often sides with issuers than with private investors.
The same discussion touched on auditors, on whom trust in issuers' financial statements depends. The head of the Moscow Exchange's supervisory board, Sergei Shvetsov, proposed radically reducing the number of audit companies, while Chistyukhin advocated for stricter admission to their register — this could improve the quality of financial reporting, although checks will probably become more expensive for businesses.
At the same time, the venue through which 212.9 trillion rubles passed in October defends its interests not only in dialogue with the Central Bank but also in Europe: in October, the Moscow Exchange filed a lawsuit against the EU Council in a European court following the European Union's July sanctions.
Cryptalist analysis: The structure of the Moscow Exchange's turnover shows that record volumes largely reflect money market and REPO activity rather than capital inflow into equities. This makes local rallies in low-liquidity IT stocks vulnerable to a rapid reversal once speculative demand is exhausted. Investors would be well advised to focus on issuers' fundamental indicators and the quality of information disclosure, rather than on record figures for aggregate turnover.