The Goldman Sachs Panic Index recorded the largest two-day move in its entire history, surpassing the record of April 2013. The indicator fell sharply amid the post-midterm election rally, and the very next day it jumped to 9.57 out of 10.
The measure pushed US equities into panic territory — this threshold has been crossed only 15 times in history. Typically, such situations preceded gains in the S&P 500, but traders believe forced selling may continue.
Why the Goldman Sachs Panic Index reversed within 48 hours
The index is calculated by Goldman Sachs' trading division. It assesses stress in the US equity market on a scale from zero to 10. It is based on signals from the options market: implied volatility and the cost of downside protection.
The total movement of the indicator over two days was approximately 8.5 points. The previous record was set on April 16, 2013, at 7.87 points.
The sharp move began on Wednesday, November 4. Stocks rose after the Democrats' victory in elections for both chambers of Congress, and the Dow added 3% on post-election optimism.
Clients used this rally to sell off protective positions. As a result, the panic index recorded the fourth-largest one-day drop in history.
Protection disappeared right on the eve of when investors needed it. On Thursday, a selloff in AI chipmaker stocks sent the S&P 500 down 4.36% — the worst session since April 2025.
That day the index rose by about five points — the third-largest daily gain. Goldman Sachs trader Lee Coppersmith described the reversal: "The two-day move was the largest in the index's history — in my view, it illustrates well how quickly the market shifted from optimism to outright panic."
Demand for protection also set a record. On Thursday, the Cboe exchange processed 11.23 million put options — more than the previous maximum of 10.22 million contracts on April 4, 2025.
Does the record panic level point to a rebound
Goldman Sachs' historical data offers hope for a positive outcome. Observations show that after the previous 15 instances of the indicator spiking above 9.5 points, the S&P 500 gained about 4.6% over the following three months.
In 80% of such cases, stocks rose. Over six months, the average gain reached 9%, and the success rate reached 73%.
Coppersmith attributed the selloff not only to deteriorating fundamentals but also to poor positioning and forced hedge adjustments. "It's too early to rush into risk assets, but ignoring the potential opportunity on the other side is becoming increasingly difficult," the trader noted.
If forced selling continues, it will take more time for the historical scenario to play out.
A second indicator points to fear, but not panic
On Tuesday, November 10, CNN's Fear and Greed Index showed 33 points — the fear zone. A week earlier, the reading was at 23, corresponding to the extreme fear zone. After Thursday's crash, it dropped to 20, when the VIX spiked 70%.
Buyers returned to the market. The S&P 500 rose 2.35% on Monday — the best result since April 8.
Two records in one week — in hedging volume and in the scale of panic moves — confirm that short-term positioning has become overloaded. Whether the rebound holds depends less on the elections and more on AI spending, which triggered Thursday's decline.
Cryptalist analysis: The record reversal of the Goldman Sachs Panic Index reflects not so much fundamental weakness in the market as the scale of forced hedge adjustments and overloaded short positions. Historical statistics favor an S&P 500 rebound over three- and six-month horizons, but the durability of the recovery will be determined by the dynamics of AI capital expenditures. For the cryptocurrency market, such volatility traditionally acts as a factor of heightened risk in the short term.