The correspondence between Nvidia's head of press service and the authors of an analytical newsletter, which has become publicly available for the first time, sheds light on one of the most acute questions surrounding US export controls: whether the chipmaker's Singapore revenue actually conceals shipments of AI accelerators to China. Nvidia's response came the day after the request — and the company directly disputed the analysts' conclusions.

The crux of the disagreement lies in the interpretation of the financial statements. Nvidia's revenue from Singapore over three quarters reached $17.4 billion, while from China it was $11.6 billion. At the same time, the number of data centers was distributed radically differently: about 5,375 in the US, 448 in China, and only 99 in Singapore. At first glance, the city-state with a hundred sites was bringing the company more money than all of China — and this looked like a clear signal of re-export.

What Nvidia responded

In the letter, the company's press service explained that the financial statements indicate the billing address, not the delivery address. Singapore in the documents means the place where the client pays for the purchase, not the country where the chips go. According to Nvidia representatives, many customers hold legal entities in Singapore and purchase equipment through them for the US and Western countries. The company also referred to its quarterly report on Form 10-Q: most of the shipments associated with Singapore revenue were directed to other countries, and to Singapore itself — in an insignificant volume.

Nvidia also assured that it requires partners to comply with all laws and responds to any information about violations, insisting that the company has no reason to believe that US national security or its trade secrets have been compromised.

Context and scale of risk

The chronology deserves special attention. Since the founding of the Chinese AI model developer DeepSeek, Nvidia's sales to Singapore have grown by 740%, and US authorities have already checked whether DeepSeek purchased graphics processors through intermediaries in that country. According to shipment data, the route through Singapore has been operating since 2023, and Chinese buyers, through a network of companies in China and Singapore, could have obtained about 240,000 Nvidia chips worth $7.5 billion. A direct link between these shipments and the discrepancies in revenue has not yet been established.

The main risk for investors is the scale: Nvidia's explanations concern revenue in the billions of dollars. If the investigation shows that some of the chips were indeed going to China, regulators will have questions about the reliability of the company's financial statements, and Nvidia itself risks facing fines and stricter control of sales in Asia.

Cryptalist analysis: The case demonstrates the fundamental vulnerability of export controls built on the geographic attribution of revenue: the billing address and the delivery address are different entities, and this creates room for interpretation. For the market, what remains key is not the rhetoric but the outcome of the checks — it is this that will determine whether the premium to Nvidia's shares and the stability of the entire AI infrastructure sector will be preserved.