China's four largest AI labs may have trained their latest models on Nvidia chips whose export to the country is banned. Traces of the prohibited hardware were found directly in the published weight files of the models.

These are Blackwell processors — Nvidia's most powerful chips for artificial intelligence tasks. Their supply to China is restricted by U.S. authorities: selling such accelerators requires a U.S. license, and no issuance of one has been reported. Accordingly, any shipments of these chips to Chinese customers are considered a violation of export controls.

Detection method: a digital fingerprint of the hardware

Almost every AI model contains a hidden marker of the hardware on which it was trained. Before training, the model is initialized with seed values whose pattern depends on the specific chip and the seed — the initial value of the random number generator. Traces of this pattern are preserved in the finished model and can be analyzed.

The study brute-forced more than six trillion "chip — seed" combinations. Matches with Blackwell were identified in six models:

  • DeepSeek-V4-Flash and DeepSeek-V4-Pro from DeepSeek;
  • Kimi K3 and Kimi K3.1-Pro from Moonshot AI;
  • MiniMax-M3 from MiniMax;
  • Ling-3.1-flash from Ant Group.

Earlier models from the same labs were built on the previous-generation Hopper chips. The result was verified on real hardware: a Blackwell chip with the discovered seed exactly reproduced the seed values of the DeepSeek-V4-Flash model, whereas the previous-generation chip produced not a single match. The findings were independently confirmed by senior specialists at OpenAI and Anthropic. The value of the banned chips at the four labs is estimated at more than $500 million.

Context: Nvidia chief's resignation and debate over the consequences

The investigation emerged against the backdrop of Nvidia chief Jensen Huang's resignation over a scandal involving a possible technology leak. Some observers believe that if the findings are confirmed, he could face criminal prosecution. Huang previously admitted to an extramarital affair with Alice Huang, head of the Singapore-based firm Megaspeed, which is suspected of supplying banned Blackwell chips to China's DeepSeek.

Lex Fridman called Huang's departure a huge mistake for the U.S. and all of humanity, comparing the situation to Steve Jobs' ouster from Apple, but with more serious consequences — since AI determines the future of the world. He also pointed to the mass hysteria surrounding this story.

Cryptalist analysis: The discovery of Blackwell traces in the publicly available weight files of Chinese models is not merely a technical finding but a signal that U.S. export controls may have systemic circumvention channels, which casts doubt on the effectiveness of the sanctions regime. For the market, this creates dual pressure: on the one hand, reputational and regulatory risks for Nvidia; on the other, an acceleration of the AI-capacity race in Asia. Investors should closely monitor the development of the investigation, as it could affect Nvidia's valuation and the dynamics of the semiconductor sector as a whole.