The Moscow Exchange is challenging in the Court of the European Union the sanctions imposed against it in July under the 21st package of restrictions. The plaintiff insists that the EU Council adopted the decision with gross procedural violations and without a full dossier of evidence. For Russian investors, the outcome of the dispute could either weaken the isolation of the country's key trading venue or entrench the restrictions for a long time.
EU sanctions complicate settlements with European counterparties and access to foreign infrastructure. Court proceedings in the EU, as a rule, last a long time, so investors should not expect rapid changes.
What the Moscow Exchange accuses the EU Council of
A statement of the exchange's arguments was published in the Official Journal of the EU on November 16. According to the plaintiff, the Committee of Permanent Representatives (Coreper) was supposed to prepare a case dossier for the ministers in advance, but none existed.
Because of this, according to the Moscow Exchange, the EU Council did not conduct a personal assessment of the company's situation and adopted the decision without knowing all the material facts. The ministers, according to the plaintiff, did not have access to the full set of evidence.
In total, the venue cites four grounds for annulling the sanctions: breach of the obligation to state reasons for decisions, errors in assessing the circumstances, failure to comply with essential procedural requirements, and violation of the principle of proportionality. The EU Council's arguments, according to the exchange's representatives, are vague, erroneous and unsupported by evidence.
The venue's management considers the restrictions disproportionate and in violation of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights regarding freedom to conduct a business and the right to property. The Moscow Exchange demands the annulment, insofar as it concerns it, of EU Council Decision 2026/1845 and Implementing Regulation 2026/1843 of July 23, 2026, and that the legal costs be borne by the Council.
The European Union added the exchange to the sanctions list in July under the 21st package of restrictions. Brussels explained this by saying that the venue provides material or financial support to the Russian government or receives benefits from it, and called it a center of domestic financing and trading in Russia. The Russian authorities, in turn, have repeatedly called the EU's unilateral sanctions illegal and stated that the economy has adapted to them.
The lawsuit, the index and trading: what else matters to investors
The Moscow Exchange filed the lawsuit with the EU court back on October 5, more than a month ago, but the substance of the claims was not disclosed at the time. From the published arguments it is clear that the plaintiff is relying primarily on procedural violations by the EU Council.
The Moscow Exchange index on November 12 exceeded 2,500 points for the first time since late October. The market reacted this way to trilateral talks between Russia, the US and Ukraine in Abu Dhabi. Any signs of detente support demand for Russian stocks, so the fate of the sanctions, including the exchange's lawsuit, remains one of the main reference points for investors.
Two weeks ago the venue announced that it will not hold trading on the stock and derivatives markets on December 31. This should be taken into account when planning trades at the end of the year: in the event of sudden news, including on sanctions, it will not be possible to close a position on the last day of the year.
Cryptalist analysis: The Moscow Exchange's lawsuit is built on procedural arguments rather than on challenging the factual basis of the sanctions, which makes it legally vulnerable but a potentially significant precedent for revising EU regulations. Given the length of proceedings in the EU court, the market is unlikely to get a quick catalyst, but the very fact of the dispute increases uncertainty around infrastructure risks and settlements for Russian participants.