The bubble in the US stock market has inflated not in AI company stocks, but in defensive securities, where investors hide from risks related to artificial intelligence. An analysis of forward multiples and earnings growth rates shows that overvaluation is concentrated precisely in the "safe haven."

Defensive stocks turned out to be more expensive than technology ones

This concerns the consumer staples sector — manufacturers of food, household chemicals, and other goods that people buy in any economy. Such stocks are traditionally considered a "safe haven."

The comparison is based on forward P/E according to FactSet data. This indicator reflects how much investors pay for each dollar of earnings expected over the next 12 months. The higher it is, the more expensive the stock. The picture turned out as follows:

  • consumer staples — 23.7;
  • S&P 500 index — 18.3;
  • technology sector — 18.

At the same time, earnings at defensive companies are growing much more slowly. For 2027, analysts expect growth of 6.4%. For the S&P 500, the forecast is 16.2%, and for technology companies — 42%. In the past quarter, the gap was even more noticeable: earnings in the consumer sector grew by about 4%, while in the technology sector — by 69%.

Valuing expected growth gives the price of one percentage point of earnings growth. For defensive stocks it came out to 3.7, for the S&P 500 — 1.1, and for technology securities — 0.4. It turns out that investors pay almost nine times more for the growth of toothpaste and cereal makers than for the growth of technology companies.

Forward P/E, expected earnings growth in 2027, and price per unit of growth in three segments of the US market
Forward P/E, expected earnings growth in 2027, and price per unit of growth in three segments of the US market.

How the flight from risk could end

Technology stocks became cheaper relative to earnings because earnings themselves rose sharply. The opposite happened with defensive securities. They became more expensive while their fourth-quarter earnings forecasts were declining by 4%. This situation is described as a crowded fear trade: too many investors are making the same bet at the same time.

A telling example is XLP, an exchange-traded fund that invests in consumer sector stocks. Over six weeks it rose by about 16%, and trading took place on the highest volumes of the year.

The logic of a reversal is based on the base effect: in the spring, annual inflation will decline against the backdrop of high prices from last year, against which the current growth looks weaker. When the Fed stops raising rates, investors will begin to exit defensive securities.

For investors, this is a signal that the "safe haven" currently carries risks. A high price with weak earnings growth will make such stocks vulnerable if fear in the market weakens.

Cryptalist analysis: The overvaluation of the defensive sector reflects not the fundamental strength of the business, but a mass outflow of capital from AI stories into defensive positions. As rates normalize and inflationary pressure eases, this overhang could collapse faster than the market expects, which makes the consumer sector a zone of heightened risk rather than a refuge. For the cryptocurrency market, this is an additional argument in favor of liquidity being redistributed into risk assets as fear weakens.