A hypothetical quantum attack could empty the most vulnerable Bitcoin wallets in about an hour. However, no machine capable of implementing such a scenario exists today.

This conclusion was reached by Grok, the chatbot from Elon Musk's xAI, while evaluating the forecast of cybersecurity expert Jameson Lopp. The neural network confirmed the theoretical validity of the scenario but pointed to its purely hypothetical nature.

What an attack over six blocks might look like

According to Lopp's estimate, a quantum attack could deprive owners of 95% of the most vulnerable bitcoins in about an hour. "By my estimate, it would take about six blocks to withdraw these BTC," the expert noted.

A block is a package of transactions that the Bitcoin network adds on average once every ten minutes. No one would know about the attack until large transfers appear in the blockchain.

Grok called such a scenario realistic, but with a caveat. It would require a quantum computer that cracks Bitcoin keys in minutes or hours using Shor's algorithm. This is a quantum computing method that allows deriving a private key from a public one. Bitcoin keys are built on the secp256k1 mathematical curve, and it is precisely this that such a machine would have to defeat.

According to Grok's description, the attack would proceed in two stages:

  • first, the attacker covertly, without connecting to the network, recovers the keys to vulnerable addresses;
  • then withdraws coins from the largest wallets, and these transactions could fit into approximately six blocks.

The chatbot called addresses whose public keys are already visible in the blockchain vulnerable. These are early-format P2PK addresses and those that were reused. They account for about 35% of the Bitcoin supply.

The threat remains theoretical

Grok emphasized that no suitable machine exists today. Current quantum systems have too few logical qubits. A qubit is the basic element of a quantum computer. Logical qubits are those protected from errors and suitable for complex computations.

The main obstacle, according to the chatbot's assessment, is creating the hardware, not the withdrawal of coins itself. Grok also noted that Lopp described the scenario as hypothetical and relating to the future, not as an imminent threat.

For Bitcoin holders, this means that right now their coins are not at risk. The risk is tied to the future and concerns primarily old-format addresses and those that were reused.

Cryptalist analysis: The quantum attack scenario remains theoretical, but it exposes a structural vulnerability: about 35% of the BTC supply is concentrated in addresses whose public keys are already revealed in the blockchain. As quantum computing progresses, the topic of migrating to post-quantum signature standards will become increasingly important for the long-term resilience of the network. Investors should view this as a distant but systemic risk, not as an immediate threat to current positions.