The Russian Ministry of Finance assumes that the introduction of a progressive tax scale on passive income starting next year will not force private investors to revise their strategies. The key risk for capital holders, according to the ministry, is not the tax itself but the potentially higher rate that will arise after investment income is combined with labor income. Tax deductions, which the Ministry of Finance promises to keep unchanged, are intended to soften the tax burden.
The reform will primarily affect citizens with low incomes only minimally — the main blow may fall on brokers and management companies, for whom a decline in the attractiveness of investments in stocks and funds will result in an outflow of their client base. The ministry emphasizes its readiness to take the market's position into account and continues consultations with its professional participants.
What the Ministry of Finance guarantees
According to Finance Minister Ivan Chebeskov, the ministry has held a series of discussions with professional market participants regarding the mechanisms of individual investment accounts (IIAs) and mutual investment funds (MIFs). The ministry declares its openness to dialogue and readiness to hear players' concerns. The official's main argument is the stability of tax deductions.
"In our view, there is currently no need to have any concerns and one should take advantage of the benefits that are provided. And first of all, of course, these are tax deductions, which are not changing," he noted.
After the reform, investment income will be summed with labor income rather than taxed separately. Under a progressive scale, some investors risk ending up in a higher rate bracket — and it is precisely deductions that will become their main tool for reducing the tax burden.
What else influences private investors' decisions
Chebeskov acknowledged that the stock market is not approaching its 2030 targets: the capitalization of companies on the exchange is about 20% of GDP, whereas according to a presidential decree it must reach 66%. To turn the situation around, a coordination council will be created under the government; however, if private investors flow out due to tax changes, achieving the goal may become even more distant.
At the same time, the Ministry of Finance does not always accommodate market participants: the ministry and the Central Bank did not support an amendment by bondholders seeking the right to challenge knowingly false audit opinions in court. Without such protection, buyers of debt securities risk investing in instruments of an unreliable issuer.
In parallel, the ministry is increasing purchases of foreign currency and gold under the budget rule: 312.63 billion rubles will be allocated for these purposes from November 9 to December 4 — 15.6 billion per day versus 12.7 billion in October.
Cryptalist analysis: Combining investment and labor income into a single progressive base is a hidden increase in the effective rate for wealthy investors, and assurances that deductions will remain unchanged compensate for this only partially. For the Russian stock market, which is already lagging behind its ambitious capitalization target, such a step creates a risk of slowing the inflow of retail capital. Cryptalist assesses the balance of risks as moderately negative for stocks and mutual funds, while debt instruments and alternative assets remain relatively attractive.