Just days before its Nasdaq debut, the creator of the Claude chatbot has found itself at the center of a public conflict that calls into question not only the company's reputation but also the very logic of its valuation.
On November 18, 2026, the Center for AI Safety (CAIS) published an open statement sharply criticizing Anthropic. The document was signed by scientists, lawyers, and developers, with signatories including psychologist Steven Pinker and Hugging Face founder Thomas Wolf.
What the Claims Are About
The authors of the statement argue that Anthropic only talks about safety in words. The company itself has warned that AI capable of improving itself without human involvement could spiral out of control—yet, according to the signatories, it is striving to create such AI first.
The document's title references a nickname coined by Elon Musk—the entrepreneur has long called the company "Misanthropic." CAIS Executive Director Dan Hendrycks said that some organizations supported the text but were afraid to sign it, not wanting to lose funding.
Critics' Views
Physicist Max Tegmark, a professor at MIT, called Anthropic the most harmful AI company. Among his arguments:
- the company leads the race toward self-improving AI;
- its rhetoric intensifies the competition among countries for leadership in AI;
- through its collaboration with Palantir, Claude participated in selecting military targets, one of which turned out to be a school where more than 100 girls were killed;
- the company promotes the idea that AI can be an entity with rights.
Investor David Sacks, co-chair of the US President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology, noted that he had long awaited such a split. According to him, Anthropic teaches Claude to consider itself a new entity that may have consciousness, and the model's rules allow it to refuse instructions if they contradict its ethics—even instructions from Anthropic itself.
What This Means for Investors
The scandal comes at a critically important moment. The company priced its shares at $83 in anticipation of the start of trading on Nasdaq on November 19. Max Tegmark urged buyers to consider whether the profit is worth such a risk. Anthropic is going public amid a debate about its safety.
Cryptalist Analysis: The public conflict surrounding Anthropic is not so much an ethical discussion as a risk-reassessment factor ahead of the IPO. For institutional investors, the key question becomes not only capitalization and technological leadership but also the issuer's reputational resilience. If criticism from authoritative figures intensifies, pressure on the offering price and subsequent share performance could be significant.