Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse has once again drawn attention to the controversial Bitcoin accumulation strategy of Strategy. In a recent statement, he emphasized that he remains a long-term optimist regarding the first cryptocurrency, but called Strategy's approach frankly harmful to the entire market.

According to Garlinghouse, financial engineering that does not create real value is doomed to fail. He stressed that the true long-term value of any digital asset is determined solely by its utility, not by capital manipulations.

The Problem with Preferred Shares

Strategy has been raising funds for new Bitcoin purchases through the issuance of preferred shares with a fixed dividend for about a year. The STRC paper offers investors 11.5% annual yield and, according to the issuer's plan, should trade near the $100 mark. However, reality turned out differently: the shares fell approximately 25% below this level. Garlinghouse called this a "devastating indictment" of the chosen model.

On June 26, STRC hit an all-time low, dropping to 28% below par. The session closed with the price at $74.6. Strategy's common shares (MSTR) also showed negative dynamics, falling to their lowest level since February 2024 and closing at $82.3. During the same period, Bitcoin dropped below $59,000.

Critical Indicators

The company's mNAV ratio — the ratio of market capitalization to its BTC assets — shrank to 0.99. This means the market values Strategy almost on par with its cryptocurrency reserves, which is a worrying signal for investors.

Two days earlier, CryptoQuant analysts urged Strategy to pause Bitcoin purchases and restore cash reserves. According to their estimate, the STRC dividend coverage reserve has shrunk from over seven years to approximately 14 months. This jeopardizes the company's ability to meet its obligations to preferred shareholders.

Recall that in June, Strategy founder Michael Saylor presented a five-tier model of the Bitcoin economy, which apparently did not help calm the market.

My professional commentary: The situation surrounding Strategy is a vivid example of how aggressive use of debt instruments and financial engineering can lead to a loss of market confidence. Investors should closely monitor the company's ability to generate real profit, rather than relying solely on Bitcoin's price growth. If the trend continues, Strategy may face serious liquidity problems.