Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse recently expressed optimism about Bitcoin in an interview, but sharply criticized the cryptocurrency purchase financing model used by Strategy. In his view, issuing preferred shares to accumulate BTC is nothing more than financial engineering that does not create long-term value.

"Financial engineering does not create long-term value," Garlinghouse emphasized, adding that the true value of any digital asset is determined by its utility. He pointed out that Bitcoin's long-term value should be based on its real-world application, not on complex capital-raising schemes.

For over a year, Strategy has been raising funds to purchase Bitcoin by issuing preferred shares with a fixed dividend. The STRC shares, which offer 11.5% annual interest, were designed to trade around $100. However, as the Ripple head noted, the actual share price has fallen approximately 25% below this level, which is a "devastating indictment" of the chosen strategy.

On June 26, STRC hit an all-time low, dropping to 28% below par value. At the close of the session, the price stood at $74.6. Strategy's common shares (MSTR) during the same period fell to their lowest level since February 2024, closing at $82.3. Meanwhile, Bitcoin dipped below $59,000 in the market. The company's mNAV ratio — the ratio of market capitalization to BTC assets — shrank to 0.99, indicating that the market values the company below the cost of its Bitcoin reserves.

Two days earlier, CryptoQuant analysts urged Strategy to suspend cryptocurrency purchases and rebuild cash reserves. According to their estimates, STRC's dividend coverage reserve has shrunk from over seven years to approximately 14 months, creating serious risks for holders of these shares.

My analysis: Garlinghouse's criticism highlights a fundamental problem with Strategy's model: it relies on a constant influx of new capital rather than the real utility of the asset. The sharp decline of STRC and MSTR amid Bitcoin's drop is a clear signal that the market is beginning to doubt the sustainability of this strategy. If BTC does not show a strong recovery, Strategy may face the need to reconsider its financing model, which would put additional pressure on the entire market.