A thesis has long circulated in professional circles: with each halving, Bitcoin's security steadily declines due to the reduction in miner rewards. However, a deep analysis shows that this view is nothing more than an oversimplification that fails to account for the network's complex economic architecture.
I reviewed a new report on Bitcoin's software security. In it, experts convincingly demonstrate that the resilience of the first cryptocurrency is determined not only by the issuance volume but also by a set of market incentives that make any attack economically unfeasible.
Security Beyond Hashrate
The key argument of critics is the decline in the so-called "security budget" (total miner rewards). Indeed, after each halving, BTC issuance drops by half, and by 2140 it will cease entirely. Skeptics predict that transaction fees will not be able to compensate for this loss, leaving the network vulnerable.
However, this logic ignores a fundamental factor: the asset's market value. Let me provide a clear example from the report. Before the first halving in 2012, miners' average daily revenue was only $26,300. Today, despite the block reward dropping from 50 BTC to 3.125 BTC, this figure has risen to ~$40.2 million. The growth in Bitcoin's price has more than offset the reduction in issuance.
Of course, this dynamic cannot be extrapolated indefinitely. The model described in the study assumes that the BTC price must double every four years for over a century. This is an extremely ambitious scenario. But it clearly demonstrates that security is not a static function but a dynamic process dependent on market conditions and competition among miners.
51% Attack: Expensive and Pointless
Even the hypothetical scenario of seizing control over 51% of the hashrate is not as frightening as it is portrayed. An attacker would need colossal investments in equipment and electricity. But more importantly, a successful attack would instantly erode trust in Bitcoin, and thus its value. The asset you are trying to steal or devalue would lose its worth. The economic rationale for such an operation approaches zero.
Separately, consider attacks like double-spending or transaction censorship. Even with control over 99% of the hashrate, blocked transactions will eventually be included in blocks generated by the remaining miners. Moreover, rising fees in response to censorship would instantly attract new players to the network, neutralizing the aggressor's monopoly. This is a built-in self-regulation mechanism.
A Look to the Future
This report is only the first part of a large-scale study. In subsequent publications, the authors promise to thoroughly analyze attack scenarios and the impact of changes in miners' revenue structure on blockchain resilience. It is already clear: the discussion about Bitcoin's security should not be reduced to a primitive comparison of hashrate and block reward. The reality is much more complex and interesting.
My professional opinion: The market, as always, finds its own balance. As long as Bitcoin maintains its status as "digital gold" and demonstrates long-term capitalization growth, its security will only strengthen. Fears of the "death of the network" after halvings are classic FUD that fails to account for the adaptability of decentralized systems.