The crypto community has long held the belief that each subsequent reduction in miner rewards—the halving—will inevitably weaken the security of the Bitcoin network. However, analysts at Fidelity Digital Assets propose a deeper look at this issue, challenging simplistic conclusions. In their new study, "Bitcoin's Programmed Security: Part One," they argue that the resilience of the first cryptocurrency is determined not only by the size of rewards but also by a complex system of economic incentives that make attacks extremely costly.

Security Beyond Hashrate

In the first part of the work, experts examine the concept of the "security budget"—the total income of miners from the issuance of new coins. After each halving, Bitcoin's issuance is cut in half, raising concerns about a gradual decline in the security budget. Critics of the network warn that in the future, transaction fees may be insufficient to maintain the current level of blockchain protection.

Fidelity considers this approach too one-sided. The security of digital gold, in their view, cannot be assessed solely through the lens of miner rewards or hashrate. Key factors include the market value of the asset, competition among miners, costs for equipment and electricity, as well as the economic impracticality of most potential attacks.

Notable is the historical context: before the first halving in 2012, the average daily income of miners was only $26,300. Today, this figure reaches approximately $40.2 million, despite the block reward dropping from 50 BTC to 3.125 BTC. This gap clearly demonstrates that network security can grow even as issuance declines, provided the asset's price increases.

However, experts warn that relying on endless price growth is not viable. Their model suggests that Bitcoin's price must at least double every four years for over 100 years. Therefore, the analysis must also consider attack scenarios.

51% Attack: Myth or Reality?

Fidelity notes that for a successful 51% attack, an attacker would not only need to gain control over the majority of computational power but would also incur enormous costs for equipment and electricity. Moreover, the attack itself would likely lead to a collapse of trust in Bitcoin and a sharp drop in its value, rendering such actions economically meaningless.

Theoretically, control over hashrate allows rewriting old blocks and censoring transactions. However, in practice, even possessing 99% of the power does not guarantee this—discarded transactions would still end up in blocks created by other participants. Additionally, rising fees in attempts to prioritize unconfirmed transactions would attract new miners to the network, restoring balance.

A Look to the Future

The published material is only the first part of a series. In the second part, Fidelity plans to thoroughly analyze the 51% attack scenario and examine how changes in miners' income structure will affect the blockchain's long-term resilience. As analysts emphasize, "at first glance, reducing the block reward presents a serious challenge. However, there are many mechanisms that strengthen incentives for miners and, consequently, network security."

Expert Opinion: This report is an important step forward in understanding Bitcoin's true resilience. Reducing security to just hashrate is a mistake that has long needed correction. Economic incentives and market adaptability often prove to be more powerful protective mechanisms than any technical metrics. I eagerly await the second part, where specific attack scenarios will be examined.