The topic of regular miner reward reductions—halvings—inevitably weakening Bitcoin network security has long been debated in the crypto community. However, analysts at Fidelity Digital Assets, in their latest report "Bitcoin's Programmed Security: Part One," decisively debunk this myth. My professional stance aligns with their conclusions: the resilience of the first cryptocurrency is a far more complex and multifaceted mechanism than simply the sum of rewards.
Security is not just about hashrate
The key thesis of the study is the concept of the "security budget," i.e., the total income of miners from block production. Yes, after each halving, Bitcoin's issuance is cut in half, and critics predict a collapse in network security due to insufficient fees. But Fidelity considers this view simplistic. The security of "digital gold" cannot be assessed solely by the size of the reward or hashrate. The decisive factors are the asset's market value, competition among miners, equipment and electricity costs, and, most importantly, the economic infeasibility of attacks.
Let me give a striking example from the report: before the first halving in 2012, the average daily miner income was just $26,300. Today, that figure is around $40.2 million. And this is despite the block reward dropping from 50 BTC to 3.125 BTC. Clearly, the rise in Bitcoin's price compensates for the reduced issuance, making the network only stronger. However, Fidelity rightly warns against relying entirely on endless price growth. Their model suggests that Bitcoin's price would need to double every four years for over 100 years to maintain the current level of security. Therefore, the analysis cannot ignore attack scenarios.
A 51% attack remains unlikely
Many believe that gaining control of 51% of the hashrate is enough for a successful attack. But this is a misconception. As analysts emphasize, an attacker would incur enormous costs for equipment and electricity. Moreover, a successful attack would instantly erode trust in Bitcoin and its market value, stripping the attack of economic purpose. Discussions about security too often boil down to a single metric—the volume of rewards. In practice, network resilience is determined by a whole set of market incentives and the behavior of ecosystem participants.
Double spending and blockchain censorship
Theoretically, by controlling the majority of the hashrate, an attacker could rewrite old blocks and dictate the chain's history. However, in practice, this is nearly impossible. The standard confirmation waiting time (at least six blocks on most exchanges) neutralizes double-spending attempts. Even possessing 99% of the power does not guarantee censorship—rejected transactions would end up in blocks mined by others. Furthermore, rising fees in attempts to prioritize unconfirmed transactions would attract new players to the network, further strengthening security.
The research will continue
This is just the first part of a series. In the second part, Fidelity plans to thoroughly analyze 51% attack scenarios and examine how changes in miner revenue structures will impact blockchain resilience in the future. As analysts noted: "At first glance, the reduction in block rewards poses a serious challenge. However, there are many mechanisms that strengthen incentives for miners and, consequently, network security."
My comment: The market often overestimates the risks associated with halvings, forgetting the fundamental economics of Bitcoin. The network's main asset is not the hashrate, but decentralization and economic incentives that make attacking it more expensive than the cost of the attack itself. As long as these incentives work, Bitcoin remains the most secure network in the world.