The widespread concern that each subsequent reduction in miner rewards (halving) will inevitably weaken Bitcoin's network security does not hold up under detailed economic analysis. Experts at Fidelity Digital Assets, in their new study "Bitcoin's Programmed Security: Part One," convincingly demonstrate that the security of the first cryptocurrency is a far more complex and multidimensional mechanism than simply the size of the block reward.

Security Beyond Hashrate

At the heart of the discussion lies the concept of the "security budget" — the total income of miners. Indeed, after each halving, Bitcoin's issuance is cut in half, which, at first glance, leads to a reduction in the security budget. However, as calculations show, this view is extremely simplistic. Before the first halving in 2012, the average daily income of miners was only $26,300. Today, that figure exceeds $40.2 million, despite the block reward dropping from 50 BTC to 3.125 BTC.

The key conclusion of the analysts: network security cannot be assessed solely by hashrate or reward size. The decisive role is played by the asset's market value, competition among miners, costs of equipment and electricity, and, most importantly, the economic infeasibility of conducting attacks. A potential attacker would have to incur enormous expenses on equipment and energy supply, and a successful attack would likely collapse trust in Bitcoin and its price, stripping the attack of any economic rationale.

Nevertheless, the analysts rightly warn: relying on endless price growth is not possible. Their model suggests that to maintain the current level of security, Bitcoin's price must at least double every four years for over 100 years. This makes it necessary to analyze attack scenarios, not just optimistic forecasts.

51% Attack: Theory vs. Practice

The study thoroughly examines the 51% attack scenario. Even with hypothetical control over the majority of hashrate, an attacker faces a number of insurmountable obstacles. To carry out a "double-spend" attack, one must outpace honest miners in block generation, which requires not only computational power but also time. Exchanges and services use a standard confirmation waiting time (a minimum of six blocks), making such attacks practically unfeasible in real time.

Furthermore, even possessing 99% of the hashrate does not guarantee the ability to censor transactions. Transactions discarded by the attacker would still be included in blocks generated by the remaining miners. Moreover, an attempt at censorship would lead to an increase in fees for priority transaction inclusion, which, in turn, would attract new miners to the network, restoring the balance.

A Look to the Future

The published material is only the first part of a large-scale study. In the second part, the experts plan to delve deeper into 51% attack scenarios and analyze how changes in the structure of miners' income will affect the long-term sustainability of the network.

Expert Opinion. This report is an important contribution to the discussion on Bitcoin's security. It shifts the focus from the simple metric of "block reward" to a complex economic ecosystem where participant incentives, market mechanisms, and the cost of an attack play a far more significant role than is commonly believed. This strengthens my confidence that Bitcoin, as the most decentralized and secure network, is capable of adapting to future challenges, including the threat of quantum computing, which is increasingly discussed in the community.