Experts at Fidelity Digital Assets have presented a fresh perspective on the long-term security of the Bitcoin network, challenging the established view that protection inevitably weakens after each halving. In their study, "Bitcoin's Programmed Security: Part One," they argue that the resilience of the first cryptocurrency is determined not merely by the volume of miner rewards, but by a complex system of economic incentives that makes attacks economically unviable.
Security is not just about hashrate
The key thesis of the report is a critique of the "security budget" concept, which reduces security to the total miner reward. After each halving, Bitcoin's issuance is cut in half, which, according to skeptics, leads to a decline in the security budget. However, Fidelity analysts emphasize that this approach is overly simplistic.
The data convincingly demonstrates that reality is more complex. Before the first halving in 2012, the average daily miner revenue was only $26,300. Today, despite the block reward dropping from 50 BTC to 3.125 BTC, this figure has risen to ~$40.2 million. The asset's market value, competition among miners, equipment costs, and electricity expenses are what truly shape network security.
At the same time, the authors warn that relying solely on endless price growth is risky. The model described in the report assumes that Bitcoin's price must at least double every four years for over 100 years. Therefore, the analysis must also account for attack scenarios.
51% attack: unlikely and economically unviable
Fidelity experts thoroughly examine the 51% attack, concluding that it remains unlikely. For it to succeed, an attacker would need not only to gain control over the majority of the hashrate but also to make massive investments in equipment and electricity. Moreover, a successful attack would inevitably lead to a collapse of trust in Bitcoin and a crash in its value, completely negating any potential gains.
Security discussions in the community too often boil down to a single metric—the volume of rewards. In practice, network resilience is shaped by a whole set of factors: market incentives, participant behavior, and the economic impracticality of most attacks.
Double spending and censorship: theoretical risks
Theoretically, by controlling over 50% of the hashrate, an attacker could rewrite old blocks, dictating the chain's history. However, in practice, this is nearly impossible. The standard six-block confirmation wait time, adopted by most exchanges, neutralizes attempts at rewriting. Even possessing 99% of the hashrate does not guarantee transaction censorship—rejected transactions would end up in blocks mined by others. Moreover, rising fees in response to censorship would attract new participants to the network, enhancing decentralization.
Looking to the future
The published study is only the first part of a series. In the second part, Fidelity plans to thoroughly analyze 51% attack scenarios and examine how changes in miner revenue structure will affect blockchain resilience in the long term.
Expert commentary: This report is an important step toward a more mature understanding of Bitcoin's security. The market has focused too long on simplified metrics. Bitcoin's economic model is far more resilient than commonly believed, and the key to understanding it lies in incentives, not absolute numbers.