The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) has published its annual report, offering a harsh assessment of the current state of the stablecoin market. From the perspective of the world's leading financial regulator, these assets are incapable of fulfilling the fundamental functions of money, and their further proliferation poses systemic risks.
The BIS's key argument is that none of the existing stablecoins settle transactions directly or indirectly through central bank balance sheets. This means there is no guarantee of exchange at par between the issuer and various blockchains under any market conditions. Essentially, current "stablecoins" are not a means of payment, but rather an ETF-like instrument with high redemption costs.
The report pays particular attention to the fragmentation of blockchain infrastructure. The same stablecoin issued on different L1 and L2 networks is not fungible. This creates serious compatibility and liquidity issues, which are absolutely unacceptable for a monetary instrument.
Risks and Threats
The BIS highlights several key problems: the pseudonymity of non-custodial wallets creates risks in KYC and AML/CFT, blurred issuer responsibility, low reserve transparency, and weak governance. With the current market capitalization at ~$320 billion (data as of the end of May), further growth of stablecoins could increase funding costs for traditional banks and limit lending to the real economy.
A separate and perhaps most alarming point is "stablecoin dollarization." Growing demand for dollar-denominated stablecoins in countries with unstable national currencies increases the volatility of cross-border capital flows and undermines the monetary sovereignty of these states.
Alternative from the BIS
As a solution, the BIS proposes developing a legal tokenization infrastructure under the control of central banks. This is a logical step: regulators cannot allow private issuers to create a parallel monetary system without oversight.
My analysis: The BIS's position is consistent and predictable — central banks will never cede control over money issuance to private companies. However, they cannot completely ignore the demand for stablecoins. In my view, the market is moving towards a hybrid model: regulated stablecoins for retail payments and CBDCs for wholesale settlements between banks. Investors should prepare for stricter requirements for issuers and reserves.