The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) has published its annual report, offering a highly critical assessment of the current state of the stablecoin market. According to the organization's analysts, existing "stablecoins" do not fulfill the fundamental functions of money. They do not settle transactions directly through central banks, and their redemption involves such friction that these instruments resemble exchange-traded funds (ETFs) more than a full-fledged means of payment.
Fragmentation and Compatibility Issues
Special attention in the report is given to the technical architecture. Stablecoins circulating on open blockchains suffer from serious fragmentation. Gaps between L1 and L2 solutions cause the same asset to lose fungibility across different protocols. This is not merely an inconvenience—it is a systemic flaw that undermines the very idea of a unified medium of exchange.
Risks to the Banking System and Sovereignty
The stablecoin market, whose capitalization reached $320 billion by the end of May, carries a number of hidden threats. The BIS warns: mass adoption of these assets could increase funding costs for traditional banks and, consequently, limit lending to the real economy. The risk of so-called "stablecoin dollarization" is highlighted separately. Growing demand for dollar-denominated stablecoins in jurisdictions with weak national currencies could amplify capital volatility and undermine the monetary sovereignty of these countries.
Issues of compliance with KYC and AML/CFT norms were also addressed. Pseudonymity and the use of non-custodial wallets create a zone of uncertainty regarding accountability, transparency, and asset management.
Alternative from the Regulator
As a constructive solution, the BIS proposes developing a legal tokenization infrastructure that could provide the necessary level of control and security that current stablecoins lack.
My comment: The BIS's position is not just criticism but a clear signal to the market. The organization effectively recognizes stablecoins as a "gray area" that, under current regulation, carries more risks than benefits. Investors should view this report not as routine analysis but as a harbinger of stricter regulatory requirements that could fundamentally change the rules of the game for "stablecoin" issuers.