The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) in its annual report delivered a harsh verdict on modern stablecoins: they do not meet the fundamental criteria of money. According to the organization's experts, these assets are unable to provide either direct or indirect settlements through central bank balance sheets, depriving them of the guarantee of exchange at par under any market conditions.

The key issue is technological and institutional fragmentation. Stablecoins circulating on open first- and second-layer blockchains lose fungibility across different protocols. The same token on different L1 and L2 networks effectively becomes a different asset. This makes them more similar to exchange-traded funds (ETFs) than to a full-fledged means of payment—the friction in redemption and conversion undermines the very idea of stability.

The BIS specifically emphasizes the risks associated with pseudonymity and non-custodial wallets. The lack of strict KYC and AML/CFT procedures, opaque governance, and unclear issuer liability create systemic vulnerabilities. With a market capitalization of around $320 billion (data as of the end of May), further growth of stablecoins threatens the banking system: rising funding costs and reduced lending to the real economy are just the tip of the iceberg.

The most alarming signal is the so-called "stablecoin dollarization." In countries with weakened national currencies, dollar-pegged stablecoins could trigger sharp fluctuations in cross-border capital flows and undermine monetary sovereignty. The BIS sees an alternative in the development of regulated asset tokenization infrastructure, rather than in the spontaneous growth of "stablecoins."

My comment as an analyst: The BIS's position is not just criticism but a clear signal to the market. Stablecoins in their current form indeed fail the money test: they do not scale without losing properties, lack a unified clearing mechanism, and depend on trust in issuers rather than the protocol. Until the industry solves the problem of cross-chain compatibility and creates a transparent reserve system, regulators will only tighten their rhetoric. Dollarization through stablecoins is not the future but already a current risk for developing economies.