Modern stablecoins, despite their growing popularity, are unable to perform the key functions of money — a unit of account, a medium of exchange, and a store of value. This conclusion follows from an in-depth analysis conducted by the Bank for International Settlements (BIS). According to experts, the current architecture of these assets does not allow them to serve as a full-fledged means of payment.
The main problem is that stablecoins do not settle transactions directly or indirectly through central bank balances. This means that issuers cannot guarantee exchange at par between different blockchains and platforms under any market conditions. The frictions that arise during redemption make these instruments more similar to exchange-traded funds (ETFs) than to an efficient means of payment. In fact, users face delays and fees that undermine the very idea of instant and cheap transactions.
The fragmentation of the ecosystem deserves special attention. The open blockchains on which stablecoins circulate suffer from disunity between L1 and L2 networks. The same stablecoin in different protocols is not natively interchangeable, creating additional barriers to liquidity and complicating the user experience. This contradicts the very concept of a global and seamless financial system.
Risks to Financial Stability and Sovereignty
In addition to technical limitations, the BIS highlights serious regulatory and macroeconomic risks. Pseudonymity and the use of non-custodial wallets create problems with compliance with KYC and AML/CFT requirements. Unclear issuer liability, weak reserve transparency, and governance issues only exacerbate the situation.
The market capitalization of stablecoins was estimated at $320 billion at the end of May. With further growth, this could lead to higher funding costs for banks and restrict lending to the real economy. Of particular concern is the phenomenon of "stablecoin dollarization": growing demand for dollar-denominated stablecoins in countries with weak national currencies could increase the volatility of cross-border capital flows and undermine the monetary sovereignty of these states.
As an alternative, the BIS proposes developing a legal tokenization infrastructure that could ensure greater transparency and control. Previously, the organization has already stated the need for global regulation, comparing stablecoins to investment instruments.
Expert commentary from Cryptalist: The BIS conclusions are not just criticism, but a clear signal to the market. Stablecoins in their current form are not money, but specific financial instruments with a high level of counterparty risk. Until the industry solves the fragmentation problem and ensures real convertibility at par, they will remain a niche product, not a global means of payment. Dollarization through stablecoins is a double-edged sword that could strike developing economies, and this requires immediate attention from regulators.