The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) has published sharp criticism of existing stablecoins, stating that they do not fulfill the fundamental functions of money. In its annual report, BIS experts emphasize that the current architecture of "stablecoins" does not provide for either direct or indirect settlements through central bank balance sheets. This means that issuers do not guarantee exchange at par between different blockchains and platforms under any market conditions. Essentially, such instruments resemble exchange-traded funds (ETFs) more than a full-fledged means of payment — friction during redemption and the lack of a unified settlement system make them unsuitable for the role of money.
Fragmentation and Compatibility Risks
The BIS paid particular attention to open blockchains on which stablecoins circulate. Fragmentation between L1 and L2 networks, as well as deteriorating compatibility between protocols, creates a situation where the same stablecoin in different networks is not natively interchangeable. This undermines the very idea of liquidity and universality that proponents of such assets promote.

Additionally, the report highlights risks associated with pseudonymity and non-custodial wallets: this creates serious problems for compliance with KYC and AML/CFT norms. Unclear issuer liability, weak reserve transparency, and governance issues complete the picture.
Scale of the Threat and "Stablecoin Dollarization"
According to BIS data, the market capitalization of stablecoins reached $320 billion by the end of May. The bank warns: further proliferation of these assets could increase funding costs for traditional banks and limit lending to the real economy. However, the most alarming trend is called "stablecoin dollarization" — the growing demand for dollar-denominated stablecoins in countries with weak national currencies. This could increase the volatility of cross-border capital flows and directly undermine the monetary sovereignty of these states.

As an alternative, the BIS recommends developing a legal infrastructure for asset tokenization, which, in their view, could provide greater transparency and regulatory oversight.
My comment: The BIS's position is expected and logical — central banks will always defend their monopoly on issuance. However, ignoring the real demand for stablecoins in developing economies is no longer possible. The problem is not with the instrument itself, but with the lack of unified global standards and jurisdictional clarity. Until regulators offer a working alternative, the market will seek solutions beyond their control.