The Bank for International Settlements (BIS), in its annual report, has questioned the fundamental ability of modern stablecoins to function as money. According to the organization's experts, "stablecoins" lack the key properties necessary for a reliable means of payment and store of value, and their further proliferation poses serious risks to global financial stability.

Settlement Issues and Fragmentation

A key drawback of current stablecoins is the absence of direct or indirect settlements on central bank balance sheets. This means that issuers cannot guarantee exchange at par between different blockchains and platforms under all market conditions. Redemption difficulties make stablecoins more akin to exchange-traded funds (ETFs) than a full-fledged payment instrument. Fragmentation between L1 and L2 networks exacerbates the situation: the same stablecoin in different protocols ceases to be natively interchangeable, undermining the very idea of a unified medium of exchange.

image
Source: BIS.

Risks and Dollarization

Pseudonymity and non-custodial wallets create serious challenges for Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML/CFT) compliance. Unclear issuer liability, weak reserve transparency, and governance issues amplify distrust. The stablecoin market capitalization reached $320 billion by the end of May, and the BIS warns: their widespread adoption could increase funding costs for banks and limit lending to the real economy. Of particular concern is "stablecoin dollarization"—rising demand for dollar-denominated stablecoins in countries with weaker currencies could amplify capital volatility and undermine monetary sovereignty.

image
Source: BIS.

Alternative and Conclusions

As a counterbalance, the BIS proposes developing a legal infrastructure for asset tokenization. Previously, the organization has called for global regulation of stablecoins, comparing them to investment instruments.

My expertise: The BIS's stance is predictable—central banks see stablecoins as a threat to their monopoly control over money issuance. However, the arguments about fragmentation and non-fungibility are well-founded. Until stablecoins solve the problem of cross-chain interoperability and ensure reserve transparency on par with traditional finance, they will remain a niche tool for speculators rather than a full-fledged alternative to fiat money. Investors should carefully assess the risks associated with specific issuers and blockchains.