EU countries are once again raising the issue of extending the temporary message scanning regime aimed at identifying users suspected of distributing child sexual abuse material. The initiative, actively promoted by the Cypriot Presidency of the Council of the EU, is sparking fierce debate, especially after the European Parliament voted against a similar extension in March.
In a memo obtained by journalists, the Cypriot Presidency proposes that member states move to the first reading of the draft law on June 29. This concerns the continuation of the so-called Chat Control regulation, adopted by the European Commission in 2022. Initially, this mechanism was designed as a temporary measure to derogate from strict rules on the confidentiality of electronic communications, allowing authorities to scan personal messages for illegal content. Its validity expires in April 2026.
Political Divide and Security Threat
MEPs warn that returning to this scheme not only undermines trust in the negotiation process for permanent regulation but also sets a dangerous precedent. Activists from the Fight Chat Control group have already described the situation as an attempt to push through mass surveillance of citizens under the guise of fighting crime.
"The Chat Control proposal legalizes the scanning of all private digital communications, including encrypted messages and photos. This threatens the fundamental rights to privacy and digital security of all EU citizens," activists state. According to their data, the initiative is supported by 23 EU member states. Only four countries have opposed it: the Czech Republic, the Netherlands, Poland, and Italy.
My Analysis
The situation resembles the classic conflict between security and privacy that the crypto community has observed for years. However, there is a critical nuance here: scanning encrypted messages is not just a technical challenge but a fundamental undermining of the principle of end-to-end encryption. If the EU goes ahead with this, we risk creating a precedent where "temporary" measures become permanent, and citizens' privacy is sacrificed for political expediency. In the context of cryptocurrencies, where privacy is one of the key assets, such steps should be particularly alarming.