New requirements from the European Commission under the Digital Markets Act (DMA) could trigger a surge in fraud and undermine the anonymity of user data. Google's security and privacy chiefs are raising the alarm, pointing to serious risks embedded in the current wording of the document.
According to the DMA, adopted at the end of 2022, major technology platforms, including Google, are required to open their systems and data arrays to competitors. In April, the European Commission detailed the requirements: competitors will gain access to information comparable to that used by the corporation itself — search query texts, metadata, click data, and ranking results.
Google's Vice President of Security, Heather Adkins, directly stated that in their current form, these rules will harm users in the EU. According to the company's estimates, the number of fraudulent schemes will increase, and the new DMA provisions will create a risk of de-anonymizing queries. Moreover, such data arrays will become an attractive target for hacker attacks.
The European Commission proposes mitigating threats by banning the re-identification of users and strengthening the protection of confidential information. However, Google considers these measures insufficient. Data will have to be shared with high granularity, and anonymization methods, in their view, cannot withstand attacks from professional hackers.
Independent cybersecurity expert Łukasz Olejnik emphasized in his blog that data sanitization is insufficient for such a scale of exchange. Meanwhile, representatives of DuckDuckGo believe that "the European Commission's approach fits within the existing legal framework." Alissa Cooper, Executive Director of the Knight-Georgetown Institute, called the proposed data-sharing regime "robust" and suggested involving independent experts in the review process.
Android in the Crosshairs
A separate set of requirements concerns the Android operating system. Its security lead, Eugene Liderman, warned that expanding access to permissions, the microphone, the camera, and screen information opens new opportunities for malicious actors. Notably, Apple partially supported Google's position on this issue.
Analytical Conclusion: The situation demonstrates a classic conflict between regulation and practical security. The DMA requirements, aimed at de-monopolizing the search market, could inadvertently create a "backdoor" for data leaks. In the crypto industry, where privacy is a key value, such precedents only increase demand for decentralized search solutions and zero-knowledge proof technologies that are independent of regulatory decisions.