New regulatory requirements from the European Union stemming from the Digital Markets Act (DMA) could lead to serious consequences for user privacy. Google's security and data protection executives warn that certain provisions of this law could trigger an increase in fraud and the deanonymization of search queries.
To recall, the DMA, adopted at the end of 2022, obliges the largest technology platforms, including Google, to open their systems and data to competitors. In April of this year, the European Commission specified the requirements: competitors must gain access to information at the same level of detail as the corporation itself. This concerns query texts, metadata, click data, and ranking results.
Google's Vice President of Security, Heather Adkins, emphasizes that in their current wording, these requirements could directly harm users in the EU. According to the company's estimates, the number of fraudulent schemes will increase, and the data sets themselves will become a more attractive target for hackers due to the risk of query deanonymization.
The European Commission proposes minimizing risks by banning the re-identification of users and strengthening security measures when storing sensitive information. However, Google believes this is insufficient: data will have to be transferred with a high degree of detail, and existing anonymization methods have already been repeatedly compromised by attackers.
Independent security expert Łukasz Olejnik supports this position, noting that data sanitization is ineffective on such a scale. At the same time, representatives of DuckDuckGo and the Knight-Georgetown Institute believe that the European Commission's approach fits within the legal framework and that the proposed data transfer regime is robust.
A separate set of requirements concerns the Android operating system. Eugene Liderman, responsible for OS security, warns that expanded access to permissions, the microphone, the camera, and screen information could be exploited by attackers. Interestingly, Apple has partially supported Google's position on this issue.
My analysis: The situation resembles a classic conflict between regulatory ambitions and technical reality. The DMA's requirements, aimed at demonopolizing the market, could inadvertently create new vulnerabilities. In the crypto industry, we have already seen how attempts to increase transparency lead to data leaks. The same principle applies here: the more data is open, the higher the risks for the end user. The balance between competition and privacy is not a legal but an engineering challenge.