A new round of regulatory battle between Google and the European Union threatens to have serious consequences for user privacy. In my analysis, the current requirements of the Digital Markets Act (DMA), aimed at enhancing competition, could inadvertently create loopholes for fraudsters and hackers.
The European Commission insists that Google provide competitors with access to search query data, metadata, click information, and ranking results — at a level comparable to what the corporation itself uses. On one hand, this is a step towards demonopolizing the market. On the other, as I see it, this approach undermines the basic principles of anonymity.
Google's security experts, including Vice President Heather Adkins, directly state that the DMA requirements in their current form will lead to an increase in fraud and create a risk of de-anonymizing search queries. Data sets will become a more attractive target for hackers, and the anonymization methods proposed by the EU have repeatedly demonstrated their vulnerability.
The European Commission proposes banning the re-identification of users and strengthening the protection of confidential information. However, as I believe, these are half-measures. Data will have to be transmitted with high granularity, and modern de-identification methods, as practice shows, are broken even by small groups of attackers. It is no coincidence that independent expert Lukasz Olejnik called sanitization insufficient for such a scale.
The opposite position is held by DuckDuckGo and some academic circles, who consider the EU's approach robust and propose involving independent experts for auditing. However, in my view, this merely postpones solving the fundamental problem: the more data circulates, the higher the risk of its leakage.
A separate set of requirements concerns Android. Expanding access to permissions, the microphone, camera, and screen information is a direct path to exploitation by malicious actors. It is telling that even Apple partially supported Google's position on this issue, which speaks to the seriousness of the threat.
My conclusion: Regulators, in their pursuit of competition, risk sacrificing user privacy. Without strict technical guarantees and multi-layered data protection, the DMA requirements could become a "Trojan horse" for cybercrime. The industry and the EU urgently need to reconsider the balance between openness and security, otherwise those whom the law is intended to protect will be the ones to suffer.