Recently, intense debates have been raging around the European Union's Digital Markets Act (DMA). My team of analysts is closely monitoring developments, and one of the key points is Google's position. The company's security leaders have issued a serious warning: certain provisions of the DMA could not only increase fraud but also lead to the deanonymization of user search queries.
The crux of the problem is that the European Commission is requiring Google to open its systems and data to competitors. According to clarifications published in April, third-party companies will gain access to information comparable to what the corporation itself uses: query texts, metadata, click data, and ranking results. At first glance, this is a step toward fair competition, but as I see it, enormous risks are hidden here.
Google's Vice President of Security, Heather Adkins, notes that the requirements in their current form could harm users in the EU. According to the company's estimates, the number of fraudulent schemes will increase, and the new rules will create fertile ground for hackers. Data arrays will become a more attractive target, and anonymization methods, in the opinion of Google experts, are not reliable enough. The European Commission proposes banning re-identification and strengthening the protection of sensitive information, but this is clearly insufficient — data will have to be transferred with high granularity, which breaks any anonymization algorithms.
Expert Opinions and Alternatives
Independent security expert Łukasz Olejnik supports this view, emphasizing that data sanitization is ineffective on such a scale. On the other hand, companies like DuckDuckGo see the European Commission's approach as compliant with legal standards. Executive Director of the Knight-Georgetown Institute, Alice Cooper, even calls the proposed data transfer regime robust and suggests involving independent experts for verification. However, as an analyst, I tend to agree with Google: the risk of deanonymization is too great, especially in the context of rising cyberattacks.
A separate set of requirements concerns Android. Eugene Liderman, responsible for OS security, warns that attackers will gain broader access to permissions, the microphone, camera, and screen information. Notably, on this issue, Google's position was partially supported even by Apple.
My conclusion: The DMA requirements aimed at demonopolization could turn into a serious vulnerability for the entire ecosystem. In the pursuit of competition, the regulator risks sacrificing fundamental principles of privacy, which in the long term will undermine user trust in digital services in Europe.