Regulatory initiatives of the European Union under the Digital Markets Act (DMA) could pose serious risks to user privacy. Google's security and data protection executives have issued a warning: certain requirements of the law could trigger an increase in fraud and the deanonymization of search queries. This is not just a hypothesis—it is an analysis based on the company's internal documents.
The European Commission is preparing final decisions on Google Search and Android's compliance with the DMA, which was adopted in late 2022. The main goal is to force major platforms to open their systems and data to competitors. In April, the regulator clarified exactly how Google should share information: competitors will gain access to the same data that the corporation itself uses, including query texts, metadata, click data, and ranking results.
Google's Vice President of Security, Heather Adkins, emphasizes that in their current form, these requirements will harm users in the EU. According to the company's assessment, the volume of fraudulent activities will increase, and the new DMA provisions will create a risk of query deanonymization. Moreover, such data sets will become an attractive target for hackers. The European Commission proposes mitigating risks through a ban on user re-identification and strengthening the security of sensitive information storage. However, Google considers these measures insufficient: data will have to be shared in greater detail, and existing anonymization methods are already being broken by attackers.
Independent security expert Łukasz Olejnik supports this position, noting that data sanitization is insufficient for such a scale. At the same time, DuckDuckGo holds the opposite view, arguing that "the European Commission's approach fits within the existing legal framework." Executive Director of the Knight-Georgetown Institute, Alice Cooper, calls the proposed data-sharing regime robust and suggests involving independent experts for verification.
A separate set of requirements concerns Android. Eugene Liderman, responsible for the operating system's security, warns that broad access to permissions, the microphone, camera, and screen information will allow attackers to exploit vulnerabilities. Apple has partially supported Google's position on this issue.
My analysis: The situation resembles a classic dilemma between competition and security. The DMA aims to break monopolies but ignores technical realities. Data anonymization on the scale of a search giant is an illusion, not protection. If the EU does not revise its requirements, users risk not a transparent market but a vulnerable infrastructure where personal data becomes a commodity for hackers. The crypto industry should closely monitor this precedent: similar regulatory mistakes could recur in the DeFi space.