New regulatory requirements from the European Union under the Digital Markets Act (DMA) could spell disaster for user privacy. Google's security and data protection leaders are raising the alarm: certain provisions of the law could trigger a surge in fraud and deanonymization of search queries. This is not just a hypothetical threat—it is a real risk that we must take into account.

The European Commission is currently finalizing decisions on cases regarding Google Search and Android's compliance with the new legislation. The DMA, adopted at the end of 2022, requires the largest platforms to open their systems and data to competitors. In April, the regulator clarified what exactly Google must provide: access to query texts, some metadata, click data, and ranking results—at a level comparable to what the corporation itself uses.

Google's Vice President of Security, Heather Adkins, stated outright that the requirements as they stand will harm users in the EU. The company's assessments show that the number of fraudulent schemes will sharply increase, and the new rules will create fertile ground for the deanonymization of queries. Data arrays will become a tempting target for hackers. The European Commission proposes mitigating risks by banning re-identification and strengthening the protection of sensitive information, but Google considers these measures insufficient. Data will have to be transmitted with high granularity, and anonymization methods, as practice shows, can be cracked.

Independent security expert Łukasz Olejnik confirms that data sanitization is insufficient for such scales. Meanwhile, DuckDuckGo holds a different view, considering the European Commission's approach to fall within the legal framework. Alisa Cooper from the Knight-Georgetown Institute called the proposed regime robust and suggested involving independent experts for verification.

A separate set of requirements concerns Android. Eugene Liderman, responsible for OS security, warns that attackers could exploit expanded access to permissions, the microphone, camera, and screen information. Apple has partially supported Google's position on this issue.

My expert opinion: The situation resembles a classic conflict between openness and security. The DMA aims to break down monopolies but risks opening Pandora's box. If data becomes easily accessible to competitors, it will also become easily accessible to attackers. Balance here is critical, and the current EU proposals look raw. The market needs not just rules, but technically sound protection mechanisms.