Circle Internet Group (CRCL) shares plummeted 17.55% in one day, dropping to $62. Over the past 30 days, losses for the issuer of the second-largest dollar stablecoin, USDC, have already reached approximately 40.34%. This is despite the company's recent triumph in the European market, where USDC took a dominant position after USDT's withdrawal due to MiCA requirements.

Pressure on the shares came from two fronts simultaneously. First, during the annual Russell index restructuring on June 26, 2026, the company was removed from five key growth indices. Second, concurrently, a competing stablecoin entered the market, launched with the participation of Circle's own closest partners. Let's break down what is behind this movement and what it means for investors.

What happened with the Russell indices

Circle was excluded from several major growth indices in the Russell family, including the Russell 1000 Growth, Russell 3000 Growth, and Russell Midcap Growth. This refers to the planned annual rebalancing — a procedure where the index provider reviews the composition of baskets based on formal criteria.

The significance of this event lies in the fact that funds track these benchmarks. Index funds and ETFs are required to hold securities in the same proportions as the index. Thus, when a company leaves an index, such funds mechanically sell its shares to align the portfolio with the new basket. This creates additional supply on the market, regardless of the company's fundamental performance.

What this means for investors

The first consequence will be a reduction in passive ownership. Fewer funds tied to growth indices will hold CRCL, shrinking the base of long-term holders.

The second factor is the risk to liquidity. A decrease in the number of institutional investors could widen bid-ask spreads. As a result, the stock may become more volatile. Investors should monitor trading volumes, spread widths, and revisions of target prices by analysts.

It is important to separate technical pressure from fundamental pressure. Part of the decline is due to the rebalancing effect itself, but the initial news links the 17.55% drop in one day to a separate event. The matter is that competitor Open Standard launched the alliance stablecoin Open USD. In other words, the technical sell-off coincided with increased competition in Circle's core business.

Finally, the current valuation should be considered. CRCL trades approximately 47% below the analyst consensus target, but Simply Wall St considers the stock overvalued. Insider sales over the past three months serve as an important risk signal.

Analyst's view: a blow from within

Independent analyst Shanaka Anslem Perera notes that Circle's decline is not so much related to the emergence of a competitor as to its creators. Open USD, launched with the participation of over 140 companies, was supported by Circle's own key partners. The project was endorsed by BlackRock, which manages about 80% of USDC reserves through the Circle Reserve Fund, and Coinbase, which is a co-founder of USDC and receives approximately $908 million annually for distribution. Custodian bank BNY Mellon also joined the initiative.

The core of the argument lies in Circle's business model. The company earns almost exclusively from interest on reserves, which amount to roughly $74 billion in cash and short-term U.S. government bonds. Open USD flips this logic. Instead of the issuer keeping the interest income, the new stablecoin shares nearly all the yield with the businesses that distribute it. For the distributor, the math changes, as instead of a commission for helping Circle, they can take the yield directly.

There is a nuance. Open USD is launching on the Base blockchain, which belongs to Coinbase, and Coinbase's contract with Circle is up for renewal in August. This means Circle faces negotiations with a partner that just helped bring an alternative to market.

Perera makes a caveat in favor of a fair assessment. What is happening can also be read as rational diversification. BlackRock earns on all available fronts, and Open USD launches later this year. USDC remains liquid, regulated, and in demand, while Circle's CEO insists the market is large enough for several major players.

My analysis: The fall in Circle's shares is a classic "perfect storm," where the technical factor of index exclusion coincided with an existential challenge to the business model. The emergence of Open USD with the support of Circle's key partners — BlackRock and Coinbase — calls into question the company's future monopoly on reserve yield. Investors should closely watch the negotiations for the contract renewal with Coinbase in August. This will be a key indicator of whether Circle maintains control over its ecosystem or begins to lose market share to more decentralized alternatives.