Recently, the idea that explosive productivity growth driven by artificial intelligence will be a panacea for the U.S. budget has been actively circulating in the market. However, as my calculations and analysis of the latest research show, this hypothesis does not hold up to scrutiny. Even in the most optimistic scenarios, AI can only slightly alleviate fiscal problems, not fundamentally solve them.
According to long-term forecasts, under the current legislative framework, the U.S. national debt could reach 175% of GDP by 2056. These are alarming figures, and it is no surprise that many are searching for a "silver bullet."
What the Models Show
Let's consider four baseline scenarios over a ten-year horizon: a traditional productivity shock, a shock with worker displacement, a scenario with reduced mortality and changes in healthcare spending, and a combined "disruptive" scenario.
In the "traditional" scenario, the picture indeed looks promising: the primary deficit turns into a surplus, and the annual deficit by 2036 shrinks by more than $2 trillion. The logic is simple: the economy grows faster, and the tax base expands. However, this is just the tip of the iceberg.
Further on, the model begins to "eat away" at this effect. The specific consequences of AI implementation can "bite off" more than half of the potential improvement. This is a critical point that many overlook.
Five Channels of Pressure
I identify five main factors that exert pressure on the budget in parallel with productivity growth:
- Demographics: Reduced mortality and increased life expectancy raise the number of elderly citizens and, consequently, spending on social programs.
- Labor Displacement: Automation displaces workers, increasing the burden on the transfer and benefit system.
- Arms Race: The AI race between countries could trigger uncontrolled growth in defense spending.
- Tax Shift: The shift of the tax base from labor to capital lowers the average tax rate, as capital income is taxed under different rules.
- Cost of Borrowing: The rise in the neutral interest rate makes debt servicing more expensive.
As a result, the net fiscal effect of AI implementation turns out to be much weaker than its proponents assume. Elon Musk, for example, has called AI and robotics almost the only way to solve the debt crisis, but reality is more complex.
Implications for Markets and Crypto Assets
If AI accelerates growth but simultaneously raises the neutral rate, the cost of money in the U.S. may remain high longer than investors expect. This directly impacts Treasury bond yields and the cost of servicing the national debt. The more expensive borrowing becomes, the greater the pressure on the budget and the higher the market's sensitivity to auctions and Fed signals.
For Bitcoin and other risk assets, this means their fate depends not only on AI optimism and capital inflows into the tech sector but also on the price of liquidity. As yields rise, investors tend to reduce volatile positions, favoring dollar-denominated fixed-income instruments.
Stablecoins deserve special mention. Their issuers are major holders of short-term Treasuries. The trajectory of the national debt and interest rates directly affects the yield on their reserves and, consequently, the entire crypto infrastructure. Analysts at the Bank for International Settlements have already warned that the investment boom around AI itself is becoming a source of macro-financial risks.
My conclusion: The market overestimates AI's ability to solve the U.S. debt problem. Investors should prepare for a scenario where productivity growth does not lead to a lower cost of capital but instead creates new, more complex fiscal and macroeconomic challenges. This will require us to rethink many strategies, especially in risk management and asset allocation.