On Tuesday, July 2, Tesla (TSLA) shares fell by approximately 7.5%. This marked the steepest intraday drop in recent months. The paradox is that the sell-off began immediately after the release of a report on record quarterly deliveries, which significantly exceeded Wall Street expectations.

Just three trading sessions earlier, Tesla's stock had surged more than 8% as investors priced in optimistic expectations following the announcement of the FSD v14 Lite software update for the autopilot system. However, as soon as the actual delivery figures were released, the market reacted with profit-taking.

Deliveries Beat Forecasts, But Growth Was Already Priced In

In the second quarter, Tesla delivered 480,126 electric vehicles to customers. For comparison, the average consensus forecast from analysts was only 406,024 units, while StreetAccount experts expected around 406,600 vehicles. Total production for the same period reached 451,758 units.

MetricActual ResultAnalyst Forecast
Deliveries (vehicles)480,126406,600
Production (vehicles)451,758—

The entire momentum began on June 29: Tesla shares posted their largest daily gain in a year following the release of the FSD v14 Lite update. For the first time in a long while, older models with Hardware 3 also received it. Investors had already priced in high expectations for the quarterly report, and when the numbers were confirmed, the principle of "buy the rumor, sell the news" came into play.

Why Did the Shares Still Fall?

Fund manager Gary Black noted that before the delivery reports were published, the stock prices of Tesla and Rivian were already rising. This undermines the theory that the previous rally was solely due to a new surge of interest in autopilot. Higher gasoline prices in Europe due to the conflict with Iran likely accelerated some demand. More affordable versions of the Model 3 and Model Y amplified this effect. Sales of electric vehicles produced in China rose 24.4% in June compared to the previous year, while registrations in the Norwegian market fell by 43%.

Tesla's Valuation Is Built on Autonomy, Not Sales

A large part of Tesla's valuation, at roughly $1.6 trillion today, is tied to the story of robotaxis and Full Self-Driving, rather than car sales. The U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration continues to investigate a fatal accident on June 19 involving Tesla's driver assistance system. Until the investigation is closed, regulatory scrutiny of the company's technologies persists — and it is on this foundation that Tesla currently plans to develop its robotaxi business.

Tesla will present its full second-quarter financial results on July 22. It will then become clear whether the exceeded delivery plan was accompanied by strict price control or whether the company stimulated sales through discounts, which could eat into margins.

Cryptalist Analytical Commentary: The situation with Tesla is a classic example of how the market stops valuing a company based on current operational metrics and instead focuses on the distant future. 480,000 deliveries is a strong result, but it was already priced in. The key question for investors now is not how many cars Tesla will sell this quarter, but whether Elon Musk can turn FSD from a promising technology into a real cash flow. For now, we see that even record numbers cannot prevent a stock correction if the market decides that "all the good news is already in the price."