On Tuesday, July 2, Tesla shares fell by about 7.5%. This is the sharpest intraday drop in the past year, and it occurred against the backdrop of what seemed like a triumphant quarterly report. The company shipped significantly more electric vehicles to customers than Wall Street analysts had predicted. A paradox? Not at all. Let's break down what's behind this market movement.

The decline was recorded just three trading sessions after a powerful surge in quotes. The day before, Tesla shares rose by more than 8% amid optimistic market expectations fueled by the announcement of the FSD v14 Lite software update for the autopilot system. Investors had already priced in high expectations for the quarterly report, and as it turned out, they overpriced them.

In the second quarter, Tesla delivered 480,126 electric vehicles to customers. This is significantly higher than the average expert forecast of 406,024 units. Analysts expected around 406,600 cars. Total production for the same period reached 451,758 units. It seemed like a brilliant result, but the market reacted with selling.

Why didn't the record work?

The entire dynamic began on June 29, when shares showed their largest daily gain in over a year amid the release of FSD v14 Lite, which was first received by older models with Hardware 3 equipment. However, as fund manager Gary Black noted, the share prices of Tesla and Rivian were already rising before the delivery reports were published. This undermines the theory that the previous rally was solely due to a new surge of interest in autopilot.

Higher gasoline margins in Europe due to the conflict with Iran likely accelerated some demand for electric vehicles. More affordable versions of the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y amplified this effect. Sales of electric vehicles produced in China rose by 24.4% in June compared to last year, while registrations in the Norwegian market, on the contrary, fell by 43%. This points to uneven demand and possible saturation in some key markets.

Tesla's valuation: a bet on autonomy, not sales

A large part of Tesla's valuation at around $1.6 trillion today is tied to the story about robotaxis and Full Self-Driving, rather than car sales. The U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration continues to investigate a fatal accident on June 19 involving Tesla's driver assistance system. As long as the investigation remains open, regulatory attention on the company's technologies persists—and it is on this basis that Tesla now plans to develop robotaxis.

Tesla will present the full financial results for the second quarter on July 22. Then it will become clear whether the exceeded delivery plan was accompanied by strict price control or whether the company stimulated sales through discounts, which could eat into margins.

Cryptalist expert opinion: The market has long stopped valuing Tesla as an automaker. The drop in shares amid record deliveries is a classic "sell on the news" signal. Investors are taking profits, understanding that the company's future depends not on the number of cars sold, but on the success of FSD and robotaxis. Until there are clear regulatory and technological breakthroughs in this area, Tesla's stock volatility will remain high, and any positive sales reports will only be a reason for short-term corrections.