The case concerning 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses, which threatened to reshape notions of property on the blockchain, has taken an unexpected turn. The pseudonymous defendant, John Doe 33, has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit in the New York State Supreme Court. The plaintiffs — a certain Noah Doe and two Wyoming-based companies — claim that bitcoins worth approximately 3.799 million BTC (roughly $231 billion at current exchange rates) constitute "abandoned property" and seek to have the rights to these assets transferred to them.

The list includes addresses publicly associated with Satoshi Nakamoto, as well as the infamous address 1Feex, linked to the Mt. Gox hack. The identity of the private key controller for 1Feex remains unknown. The plaintiffs cite Article 7-B of New York's personal property law, arguing that after notification, the owners did not respond, meaning the property can be considered found.

Legal Conflict: Who is the Defendant?

The defense, represented by John Doe 33, strikes at the very core of the lawsuit. He argues that Bitcoin addresses are not individuals or legal entities that can be named as defendants. According to him, the plaintiffs handed over their own USB drives containing public blockchain data to the police, which does not establish grounds for recognizing the addresses as found property. He also emphasizes that his pseudonym is not linked to the 33rd address on the list and is used solely for security reasons and due to the risk of persecution faced by owners of large crypto assets.

Galaxy's Head of Research, Alex Thorn, noted that John Doe 33 is associated with a wallet holding 5,000 BTC that has not moved since April 2014. Its balance is estimated at roughly $300 million. "The emergence of a single owner challenging the lawsuit completely changes the dynamics of the case. He points precisely to the jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are hardest for the plaintiffs to overcome," Thorn wrote. Previously, the case was proceeding against a list of addresses whose owners had not appeared in court, allowing the plaintiffs to potentially secure a ruling without a fully adversarial position. Now, that scenario is virtually impossible.

Inactivity Does Not Equal Abandonment of Property

According to analytics, about 3.5 million BTC have not moved in over 10 years, and another 6.6 million BTC have remained untouched for more than five years. Experts remind that such coins are either lost or their owners are deliberately holding them in cold storage. Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen, who filed an amicus curiae brief, urged the court to dismiss the lawsuit, stating that the law on found property applies to physical objects, not to the result of scanning a public blockchain. "Simple inactivity, no matter how prolonged, does not constitute abandonment of property," Cohen stated. He also emphasized that New York's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, mandates the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals or companies.

My Comment: This precedent is not merely a legal curiosity. It exposes a fundamental contradiction between the nature of the blockchain as a public ledger and traditional legal norms that were not designed for digital assets. If the court dismisses the lawsuit, it will reinforce the position that ownership of cryptocurrency is a matter of control over the private key, not passive observation of an address. Otherwise, we could see a flood of lawsuits from "treasure hunters" seeking abandoned assets, undermining trust in the very principle of non-custodial storage.