The high-profile legal case surrounding 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses, collectively holding approximately 3.8 million BTC, has unexpectedly gained a real opponent. The pseudonymous defendant John Doe 33 has filed a motion in the New York State Supreme Court demanding the complete dismissal of the lawsuit. Previously, the case had been proceeding unilaterally — against a list of addresses whose owners did not appear in court.

The plaintiffs — Noah Doe and two Wyoming-based companies, ABC Company and XYZ Company — filed the lawsuit on March 11, claiming that the inactive wallets constitute abandoned property. They cite Article 7-B of the New York State Personal Property Law, attempting to gain rights to the coins, which they allege were "found" and turned over to the police. However, as it turns out, this is not so straightforward.

Weakness of the Plaintiffs' Position

In his motion, John Doe 33 pointed out a fundamental legal error: Bitcoin addresses are not individuals or legal entities that can be named as defendants. Moreover, he argues that the plaintiffs effectively handed over their own USB drives containing public blockchain data to the police, rather than "found" property. This does not create grounds for declaring the addresses abandoned.

Galaxy researcher Alex Thorn commented on the situation: "The emergence of a single owner who contests the lawsuit and has the right to participate in the proceedings completely changes the posture of the case. He is pointing out precisely those jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are hardest for the plaintiffs to overcome." According to Thorn, John Doe 33 himself is linked to a wallet holding 5,000 BTC that has not moved since April 2014 — worth approximately $300 million at current rates.

Inactivity ≠ Abandonment of Property

This precedent raises an important question for the entire crypto industry. According to Bitbo, about 3.5 million BTC have not moved for over 10 years, and another 6.6 million for over five years. Such coins may be lost, stored in cold wallets, or awaiting heirs. Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen, who filed an amicus curiae brief, emphasized: "Simple inactivity, no matter how long, does not constitute abandonment of property." He also reminded that New York's abandoned property law (amended in 2022 for virtual currencies) mandates the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.

My analysis: This lawsuit from the outset looked like a legal gamble, an attempt to "appropriate" dormant coins without real rights. The appearance of a defendant willing to defend his assets reveals the fragility of the plaintiffs' position. If the court rules in favor of John Doe 33, it will create an important precedent protecting the rights of long-term holders from such expropriation attempts. The industry should be grateful for such an outcome — otherwise, we would face a wave of lawsuits against every "sleeping" address.