One of the most high-profile legal disputes in cryptocurrency history is unfolding in the New York State Supreme Court. The defendant, operating under the pseudonym John Doe 33, has filed a motion to completely dismiss a lawsuit demanding the transfer of rights to 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses. The amounts involved are colossal — approximately 3.7–3.8 million BTC, which at the current exchange rate exceeds $231 billion.

What is the essence of the claims?

The plaintiffs (Noah Doe and two companies from Wyoming) argue that these coins constitute "abandoned property" under Article 7-B of New York State law. Their logic is simple: if an owner has been inactive for a long time, the asset can be considered ownerless and transferred to the finder. The list includes addresses publicly associated with Satoshi Nakamoto himself, as well as the infamous address 1Feex, linked to the Mt. Gox exchange hack.

Why does the defense consider the lawsuit frivolous?

John Doe 33, who according to Galaxy's Head of Research Alex Thorn controls a wallet with 5,000 BTC (approximately $300 million), has put forward a killer argument. He claims that the plaintiffs did not "find" the assets in the traditional legal sense. They simply recorded public data from the blockchain onto their own USB drives and handed them over to the police. This does not constitute finding a physical object. Moreover, in his view, Bitcoin addresses are not legal entities and cannot be named as defendants.

Alex Thorn rightly noted that the emergence of a real defendant with a voice completely changes the dynamics of the case. Until now, the case was proceeding against a "list of addresses" whose owners remained silent. The defense points to fundamental jurisdictional and legislative flaws that the plaintiffs will find extremely difficult to overcome.

Inactivity ≠ abandonment of property

This principle has become the cornerstone of the defense's position. Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen, who filed an amicus curiae brief, emphasized that the law of found property applies to physical objects, not to the result of scanning a public blockchain. According to Bitbo, approximately 3.5 million BTC have not moved for over 10 years. Many of these are not lost coins but funds in cold storage that investors intentionally leave untouched.

Cohen also reminded that New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, mandates that such assets be transferred to the state comptroller, not to private individuals. This creates an additional legal barrier for the plaintiffs.

My view as an analyst: This lawsuit is an excellent test of the maturity of crypto jurisdiction. If the court rules in favor of the plaintiffs, it would create a dangerous precedent, allowing the "privatization" of long-inactive but not lost funds. Fortunately, the defense's arguments appear far more convincing from the perspective of both the letter of the law and common sense. Most likely, we will see the lawsuit dismissed, which would be an important victory for the principles of decentralization and the rights of private key holders.