The New York State Supreme Court has received a motion to dismiss a lawsuit concerning rights to 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses. The pseudonymous defendant, John Doe 33 — the owner of one of these wallets — filed documents challenging the very legal basis of the claims. The plaintiffs, acting under the names Noah Doe and two Wyoming LLCs (ABC and XYZ Company), argue that the coins on these addresses constitute "abandoned property" and demand that rights to them be transferred to them.
This involves a colossal sum — approximately 3.799 million BTC, which at the current exchange rate amounts to about $231 billion. The list includes addresses publicly associated with Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto, as well as the legendary address 1Feex, linked to the Mt. Gox exchange hack. The key point: the identity of the controller of the private key for 1Feex has not yet been established, making this lawsuit particularly dubious from a legal standpoint.
Nature of the Claims and Defense
The plaintiffs rely on Article 7-B of New York's personal property law, arguing that inactive wallets are property whose owners did not respond after notification. However, John Doe 33's defense counters: Bitcoin addresses are not legal entities that can be named as defendants. Moreover, John Doe 33 states that the plaintiffs effectively handed over their own USB drives containing public blockchain data to the police, which does not create a basis for recognizing the addresses as found property.
Alex Thorn, head of research at Galaxy, noted that John Doe 33 is linked to a wallet holding 5,000 BTC (about $300 million) that has not moved since April 2014. According to him, the appearance of a real owner challenging the lawsuit completely changes the dynamics of the case: "He is pointing out exactly those jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are hardest for the plaintiffs to circumvent." Previously, the case was proceeding against a list of addresses whose owners did not appear in court, allowing the plaintiffs to hope for a resolution without a full adversarial position.
Inactivity ≠ Abandonment of Property
According to Bitbo, about 3.5 million BTC have not moved for over 10 years, and another 6.6 million for over five years. This does not necessarily mean loss: many investors deliberately store keys in cold wallets without making transactions. Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen, who filed an amicus curiae brief, emphasized: "Simple inactivity, no matter how long, is not an abandonment of property." He also pointed out that New York state's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, provides for the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.
My comment: This precedent is a serious signal for the entire industry. Attempts to "appropriate" dormant bitcoins through the courts lack a solid legal foundation. The blockchain is a public ledger, not a lost-and-found pile. If the court dismisses the lawsuit, it will strengthen the principle that ownership of crypto assets is protected even during prolonged inactivity. Otherwise, we risk facing a wave of similar lawsuits that would undermine trust in the fundamental principles of decentralized ownership.