A high-profile case concerning the rights to nearly 40,000 inactive Bitcoin addresses, including wallets attributed to Satoshi Nakamoto himself, has taken an unexpected turn. The defendant, operating under the pseudonym John Doe 33, has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit in the New York State Supreme Court. This move could completely dismantle the legal framework constructed by the plaintiffs.
To recap the essence of the claims: On March 11, a lawsuit was filed on behalf of a certain Noah Doe and two Wyoming LLCs, seeking to declare 39,069 long-term inactive BTC addresses as "abandoned property." This involves a colossal sum — approximately 3.799 million BTC, worth about $231 billion at the time of writing. The list includes addresses from the Satoshi era and the infamous 1Feex, linked to the Mt. Gox hack.
Why the lawsuit could collapse
The plaintiffs appeal to Article 7-B of New York's personal property law, arguing that prolonged inactivity by owners equates to relinquishing rights. However, John Doe 33, in his argumentation, points to a fundamental error: Bitcoin addresses are not legal entities or physical objects that can be "found" and "claimed." He asserts that the plaintiffs essentially handed over their own USB drives containing public blockchain data to the police, which does not create a legal basis for declaring property as found.
This argument strikes at the heart of the case. If the court agrees that addresses cannot be defendants, the entire lawsuit loses its procedural foundation. Galaxy's Head of Research, Alex Thorn, noted that the emergence of a real owner who contests the lawsuit and has the right to participate in the proceedings fundamentally changes the dynamics. He specifically points to jurisdictional and legislative flaws that will be the hardest for the plaintiffs to overcome.
Inactivity ≠ abandonment of property
Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen, who filed an amicus curiae brief, also called for the dismissal of the lawsuit. He emphasizes: "Simple inactivity, no matter how prolonged, does not constitute abandonment of property." Furthermore, New York State's abandoned property law (amended in 2022 for virtual currencies) mandates that such assets be transferred to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.
According to Bitbo, approximately 3.5 million BTC have not moved in over 10 years, and another 6.6 million have not moved in over five years. However, this does not mean the coins are lost. Many holders deliberately store keys in cold wallets, refraining from transactions for years. The death of an owner also does not render property "ownerless" — access depends on inheritance.
My analysis: This lawsuit is a classic example of an attempt to exploit legal uncertainty to seize others' assets. The emergence of a real defendant willing to defend their rights sharply reduces the plaintiffs' chances. The judge will likely dismiss the lawsuit unless compelling evidence is presented that the owners indeed abandoned their coins. For now, this serves as a reminder: prolonged wallet inactivity does not make it lawful spoils.