A new round of confrontation is brewing around the high-profile lawsuit over ownership of nearly 3.8 million dormant bitcoins. The pseudonymous defendant, identified in the case as John Doe 33, has filed a motion to dismiss all claims in the New York State Supreme Court. This move could completely derail the ambitious plans of the plaintiffs, who are attempting to legalize the seizure of crypto assets, considering them abandoned property.

Recall that the lawsuit was filed in March on behalf of an anonymous Noah Doe and two companies registered in Wyoming. They are laying claim to 39,069 addresses, which they assert are unclaimed. This involves a staggering amount — approximately 3.7-3.8 million BTC, which at the current exchange rate exceeds $230 billion. The list includes addresses publicly associated with Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto, as well as the infamous 1Feex wallet linked to the Mt. Gox exchange hack.

Legal battle for Satoshi's bitcoins

The plaintiffs base their argument on New York State's personal property law, claiming that inactive wallets constitute "found property" whose owners have not come forward after public notices. However, John Doe 33 delivers a devastating blow to this logic. In his motion, he asserts that the lawsuit itself is untenable because Bitcoin addresses are not legal entities and cannot be defendants. Moreover, he claims that the plaintiffs essentially handed over their own USB drives containing public blockchain data to the police, which does not constitute grounds for declaring property as found. The defendant himself emphasizes that he uses a pseudonym for security reasons, fearing persecution from owners of large crypto assets.

Galaxy's Head of Research, Alex Thorn, noted that John Doe 33 is likely connected to a wallet holding 5,000 BTC that has not moved since April 2014. The emergence of a real defendant contesting the lawsuit completely changes the dynamics of the case. He highlights jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are virtually insurmountable for the plaintiffs. Until now, the case was proceeding against a list of addresses whose owners remained silent, creating a risk of a default judgment.

Inactivity is not abandonment of property

According to analytics, approximately 3.5 million BTC have not moved for over a decade. These could be either irretrievably lost coins or assets held in cold wallets by investors unwilling to transact. In the event of an owner's death, access may be hindered due to a lack of inheritance mechanisms.

Earlier, Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen filed an amicus curiae brief with the court, urging the dismissal of the lawsuit. He argued that the law on found property applies to physical objects, not to the result of scanning a public blockchain. "Simple inactivity, no matter how long, is not an abandonment of property," Cohen stated. He also pointed out that New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, mandates transferring such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.

Expert opinion: This precedent is a serious test for the entire crypto industry. If the plaintiffs had succeeded in gaining control over assets without the owners' consent, it would create a dangerous mechanism for "treasure hunting" and undermine the fundamental principle of decentralization — the right to ownership of private keys. The emergence of a defendant willing to defend their rights is the best scenario for preserving the integrity of the system.