One of the most high-profile legal disputes in cryptocurrency history is unfolding in the New York State Supreme Court. The defendant, operating under the pseudonym John Doe 33, has filed a motion to dismiss claims in a case involving 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses. The lawsuit was initiated on March 11 on behalf of an anonymous Noah Doe and two Wyoming-registered companies — ABC Company and XYZ Company.

The plaintiffs claim that the funds in these addresses, estimated at approximately 3.799 million BTC, constitute abandoned property, and demand that the rights to them be transferred to themselves. Timechain Index founder under the handle Sani estimates this volume at 3.7 million BTC, which at the current exchange rate amounts to about $231 billion. The list includes addresses publicly linked to Satoshi Nakamoto himself, as well as the infamous address 1Feex, associated with the Mt. Gox exchange hack. The identity of the private key controller for 1Feex remains unknown.

The Essence of the Legal Conflict

The plaintiffs base their argument on Article 7-B of New York State's personal property law. They insist that inactive wallets can be considered property whose owners have not responded after notification. However, John Doe 33's defense puts forward a fundamentally different thesis: Bitcoin addresses are not legal entities that can be named as defendants.

John Doe 33 claims that the plaintiffs effectively handed over to the police their own USB drives, onto which they themselves recorded public data from the blockchain. According to his version, this does not create a basis for recognizing the addresses as found property. He also emphasized that his pseudonym does not imply a connection with the 33rd address on the list, but is used solely for security and privacy reasons, given the risks of physical persecution faced by owners of large crypto assets.

Inactivity Is Not Abandonment of Property

Data from Bitbo shows that about 3.5 million BTC have not moved for over ten years, and another 6.6 million BTC for over five years. Such coins are either irretrievably lost, or their owners are deliberately storing private keys in cold storage. In the event of the owner's death, access may depend on inheritance and key transfer.

Earlier, Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen filed an amicus curiae brief with the court, urging the dismissal of the lawsuit. He argued that the law on found property applies to physical objects, not to the result of scanning a public blockchain. "Simple inactivity, no matter how long, is not an abandonment of property," Cohen stated. He also noted that New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, provides for the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals or companies.

My comment: This lawsuit is a direct attack on the fundamental principle of inalienable property rights in the blockchain. If the court sides with the plaintiffs, it would create a dangerous precedent, allowing challenges to rights over any long-term holdings. Fortunately, the emergence of a real defendant with a clear legal position sharply reduces the chances of success for this dubious scheme.