The high-profile case involving an attempt to claim 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses, containing an estimated 3.8 million BTC (over $230 billion), has taken an unexpected turn. The pseudonymous defendant, John Doe 33, filed a motion in the New York State Supreme Court demanding the lawsuit be dismissed entirely. The plaintiffs — "Noah Doe" and two Wyoming-based companies — argued that these coins constitute "abandoned property" and should become their own. However, the defense has dealt a devastating blow to this logic.
Legal Trap: Addresses Are Not Defendants
John Doe 33's key argument is that Bitcoin addresses are neither individuals nor legal entities. Consequently, they cannot be named as defendants in a lawsuit. According to the defense, the plaintiffs effectively handed over their own USB drives containing public blockchain data to the police, which does not create a legal basis for recognizing the addresses as "found property." This is a subtle but critically important legal nuance that completely undermines the foundation of the lawsuit.
Why "Inactivity" Does Not Equal "Abandonment"
Many in the crypto community viewed this lawsuit as an attempt to "seize" funds that may have been lost or belonged to deceased owners. However, as Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen rightly noted, "mere inactivity, no matter how long, does not constitute abandonment of property." According to Bitbo, about 3.5 million BTC have not moved in over 10 years, and 6.6 million BTC have not moved in over five years. But this does not make them "ownerless." Many holders simply store their keys in cold storage or may have lost access, but legally, this does not give third parties the right to claim these assets.
Moreover, New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, explicitly mandates the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals or companies. This is yet another serious barrier for the plaintiffs.
Expert Opinion
This case is a classic example of how an attempt to exploit "gray areas" in legislation for quick gain runs up against fundamental legal principles. The emergence of a real defendant who contests the lawsuit completely changes the dynamics of the proceedings. If no one had objected, the plaintiffs might have tried to obtain a judgment without a full adversarial process. But now, the court will likely dismiss this lawsuit, setting an important precedent for the entire industry. Inactivity does not grant rights to another's property — this is an axiom that no legal tricks can circumvent.