A case that could have created a dangerous precedent for the entire Bitcoin ecosystem is taking an unexpected turn. The pseudonymous defendant John Doe 33 has filed a motion with the New York State Supreme Court to dismiss a lawsuit brought in March on behalf of the anonymous Noah Doe and two Wyoming LLCs. The plaintiffs are laying claim to 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses, which they estimate contain about 3.8 million BTC, worth over $230 billion at current exchange rates.

The essence of the plaintiffs' claim is based on Article 7-B of New York's personal property law: they argue that inactive wallets are abandoned property that they "found" and now want to claim ownership of. However, the defense has struck at the very foundation of this claim. John Doe 33 argues that Bitcoin addresses are not legal entities and cannot be named as defendants. Moreover, he states that the plaintiffs handed over USB drives to the police, onto which they themselves recorded public blockchain data, which does not constitute a "find" in the legal sense.

Key Point: The Real Owner Has Entered the Game

Galaxy's Head of Research, Alex Thorn, explains that the appearance of a real defendant who contests the lawsuit and has the right to participate in the proceedings completely changes the dynamics. "He is pointing out exactly those jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are hardest for the plaintiffs to overcome," Thorn wrote. John Doe 33 himself, it turns out, is linked to a wallet containing 5,000 BTC that has not moved since April 2014 (estimated value around $300 million).

Until now, the case was proceeding against a list of addresses whose owners remained silent. If no one had objected, the plaintiffs could have attempted to obtain a default judgment. Now they have a serious opponent.

Inactivity ≠ Abandonment of Property

This argument has already been reinforced by Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen, who filed an amicus curiae brief. He stated: "Simple inactivity, no matter how long, does not constitute an abandonment of property." Cohen also pointed out that New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, mandates that such assets be transferred to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.

According to Bitbo, about 3.5 million BTC have not moved in over 10 years. These could be either irretrievably lost coins or cold storage by strategic investors. Or, as in the case of the 1Feex address linked to the Mt. Gox hack, funds whose owner has never been identified.

Cryptalist's Opinion: This lawsuit is not just a legal curiosity, but a direct attack on a fundamental principle of Bitcoin: "not your keys, not your coins." If the court had sided with the plaintiffs, it would have created a mechanism for seizing any long-inactive UTXOs, undermining trust in the system. Fortunately, common sense and case law are currently on the side of the holders. But this case is a serious wake-up call for the community: it is necessary to more actively develop tools for inheriting and protecting one's assets, otherwise such lawsuits will be repeated.