The case concerning the rights to 39,069 inactive bitcoin addresses, including those attributed to Satoshi Nakamoto himself, has taken an unexpected turn. The pseudonymous defendant John Doe 33 has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit in the New York State Supreme Court, challenging the very legal basis of the plaintiffs' claims.

Let me recap the essence: On March 11, a group of individuals operating under the pseudonyms Noah Doe and two Wyoming LLCs filed a lawsuit seeking to establish their ownership rights to approximately 3.8 million BTC held in long-dormant addresses. The plaintiffs argue that these coins constitute "abandoned property," citing Article 7-B of the New York State Personal Property Law. According to their logic, they "found" this property, notified the police, and are now claiming it.

Key Defense Argument: Addresses Are Not Defendants

John Doe 33, whose identity is concealed, asserts that bitcoin addresses are not legal or natural persons that can be sued as defendants. He also points to a gross procedural error: the plaintiffs, in his version, handed over to the police USB drives containing public blockchain data that they themselves had recorded. This, in his view, does not constitute grounds for recognizing the addresses as "found" property.

The defendant's identity is of particular interest. Galaxy's Head of Research, Alex Thorn, identified John Doe 33 as the owner of a wallet containing 5,000 BTC (approximately $300 million at current exchange rates), which has not moved since April 2014. Thorn rightly notes that the appearance of a real, interested defendant completely changes the dynamics of the proceedings. The plaintiffs will now have to prove their position in an adversarial process, rather than hoping for a default judgment.

Inactivity ≠ Abandonment of Property

This case raises a fundamental question: can prolonged owner inactivity be considered an abandonment of ownership rights to digital assets? According to Bitbo data, about 3.5 million BTC have not moved in over 10 years, and 6.6 million BTC have not moved in over five years. However, as bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen, who filed an amicus curiae brief, rightly noted, "simple inactivity, no matter how long, does not constitute abandonment of property." He also emphasized that New York's abandoned property law for virtual currencies (enacted in 2022) provides for the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.

My analysis: This lawsuit initially appeared to be a legal gamble based on a strained interpretation of the law. The emergence of a defendant who has every reason to defend his rights practically guarantees that the court will not grant the plaintiffs' claims. Moreover, the very precedent of attempting to "appropriate" long-dormant coins through the courts is an alarming signal for the entire ecosystem. It shows that even the most basic principles of crypto asset ownership (possession of the private key) can be challenged in court if the legislation is insufficiently developed. Investors should closely monitor this case — its outcome could set the direction for future disputes over "digital inheritance" and rights to forgotten wallets.