The case over ownership rights to 39,069 inactive Bitcoin addresses containing approximately 3.799 million BTC (roughly $231 billion at current exchange rates) has taken an unexpected turn. The pseudonymous defendant John Doe 33 has filed a motion with the New York State Supreme Court to dismiss all claims. The lawsuit, as a reminder, was initiated on March 11 on behalf of Noah Doe and two Wyoming-registered companies — ABC Company and XYZ Company.
The plaintiffs claim that the bitcoins in these addresses constitute "abandoned property" and seek to have the rights to the coins transferred to them. The list includes addresses that public sources associate with Satoshi Nakamoto, as well as the famous 1Feex address linked to the Mt. Gox exchange hack.
The Core of the Legal Dispute
The plaintiffs base their position on Article 7-B of the New York State Personal Property Law. According to their logic, inactive wallets can be considered property whose owners have not responded after notification. However, John Doe 33 argues that Bitcoin addresses are not individuals or legal entities that can be named as defendants. Moreover, he claims that the plaintiffs effectively handed over to the police their own USB drives, onto which they themselves recorded public data from the blockchain, which does not create a basis for recognizing the addresses as "found property."
Galaxy's Head of Research, Alex Thorn, noted that John Doe 33 is linked to a wallet containing 5,000 BTC that has not moved since April 2014. In his assessment, the emergence of a real defendant contesting the lawsuit completely changes the dynamics of the case — he points to jurisdictional and legislative flaws that are the most difficult for the plaintiffs to overcome.
Inactivity Does Not Equal Abandonment of Property
According to Bitbo data, approximately 3.5 million BTC have not moved in over 10 years, and another 6.6 million BTC have not moved in over five years. Such coins are either lost, or investors are deliberately holding private keys in cold storage. In the event of the owner's death, access may depend on inheritance.
Bitcoin lawyer Ian Cohen filed an amicus curiae brief, urging the dismissal of the lawsuit. He emphasized that the law on found property applies to physical objects, not to the result of scanning a public blockchain. "Simple inactivity, no matter how long, is not an abandonment of property," Cohen stated. The lawyer also pointed out that New York State's abandoned property law, amended in 2022 for virtual currencies, provides for the transfer of such assets to the state comptroller, not to private individuals.
My analysis: This precedent is a serious signal for the entire industry. If the court sides with the plaintiffs, it would create a dangerous mechanism for seizing "dormant" funds, undermining the principle of inalienable property rights to private keys. However, the emergence of a real defendant and the defense arguments show that the judicial system can distinguish between public blockchain data and physical possession. Most likely, the lawsuit will be dismissed, but the very fact of its filing already creates uncertainty in the market.